Since I want to become a veterinarian, I researched the profession of veterinary medicine through a women’s studies lens. This profession is extremely competitive, and requires four years of additional school after college. Nearly 1,000 people apply for only 90 seats each year at Virginia-Maryland Regional College of Veterinary Medicine. Only 50 native Virginians claim seats in each year’s class. The average undergraduate GPA of the incoming students is above 3.65, meaning to be a competitive applicant, you should graduate at least magna cum laude. Incoming students also have a large number of hours of previous veterinary experience working in vet hospitals or for veterinarians. A competitive amount of experience is around 500 hours. It takes students an average of 3 years (3 separate applications, 1 each year, and 2 years failing to get in) to finally get one of the few coveted seats. It is even harder to get into vet school than it is to get into medical school, mostly due to the number of schools in the nation. There are far more medical schools (about 149, http://www.univsource.com/med.htm) than vet schools (28, http://www.aavmc.org/students_admissions/vet_schools.htm), which allow for more people to enter into the medical field than the medical field. My goal is to enter private practice for companion (small) animals, which currently is a woman-dominated subfield of veterinary medicine at 53% to 47% (http://www.avma.org/reference/marketstats/usvets.asp). Veterinary private practice as a whole is slightly male-dominated at 53.5% to 46.5%, but this number is rapidly changing as entering veterinary school is largely woman-dominated. Organizations such as the Association for Women Veterinarians have helped women take these leaps (http://www.vet.ksu.edu/AWV/about.htm).
According to http://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Veterinarian/Salary/by_Gender, the median salary of female veterinarians is $62,612. Compare this to the male veterinarian median salary of $70,829. Why the $8,000 difference? Traditionally, men were the veterinarians, as men were traditionally the doctors. This tradition in the veterinary world has since been turned upside-down. Education Acts were passed in 1972 which prevented discrimination based on sex in college admissions, allowing more women to make their way to veterinary school (http://animalpetdoctor.homestead.com/historywomen.html). Most veterinary students today are women. For example, at Virginia-Maryland Regional College of Veterinary medicine, the Class of 2011 consisted of 90 students, 25 of which were male, and 65 out of the 90 students were female—slightly over 72% (www.vetmed.vt.edu). According to http://www.anapsid.org/vets/vetdemos.html, about 75% of the 9,276 veterinarian students in the nation (including all four years) are female. Fifty years ago, only 5% were female. What does this have to do with the salary difference? A lot, actually. Another factor that plays into average salaries is experience. Obviously, the longer a vet works, the higher the salary. From the same site (clicking on median based on experience rather than gender), vets working less than one year earn $55,316. Increase that to 1-4 years and the salary increases to $61,070; 5-9 years increases to $69,117; 10-19 years increases to $73,691; 20 years plus increases to $76,127. If women didn’t start taking over the majority until the 90s, that explains why most of them haven’t reached that seventy grand mark yet. Most haven’t been vets for more than 10 years, even. The large surge of women vets are just now coming into that high experience level. As with most things concerning women in the work world, things are still changing as new generations take over and have time to reach the top. These numbers should change dramatically in another generation.
Is there vertical segregation within the veterinary medicine field? Back when men dominated the profession, veterinarians primarily worked with large animals (horses, lifestock, and other farm animals). In order to maintain the health of large animals, one must get close enough to the animal and keep it steady enough to tranquilize or anesthetize it. It is more physical as a result. The medicine and biochemistry work is relatively similar to small animals, but handling the animals of a greater size takes a bit more physical effort, unless you compare a gentle horse to a temperamental rabid cat with claws. Statistically, men aim for more physical jobs than women. As of 2007, 83.9% of the food (large, cows mostly) animal exclusive and 82.6% of the food animal predominant veterinarians in private clinical practice are male. However, these numbers even out a bit in just equine medicine in private practice—56.5% of equine veterinarians in private practice are male (http://www.avma.org/reference/marketstats/usvets.asp). This could be explained by the stereotypical little girl’s wish to have a pony. Girls love horses, and they are trying to start taking over the majority of horse doctors, as well, with time. As of late, dogs and cats have become the focus of veterinary medicine as family pets have been treated as members of the family. Puppies and kittens do not require the physical effort to wrangle as cows and horses, so perhaps this is the reason men have strayed away from the field. Most women go into small animal medicine (dogs and cats, mostly, and the occasional rabbit), and most men go into large animal medicine where the job is still considered slightly physical (http://animalpetdoctor.homestead.com/historywomen.html). Where this information seems to suggest vertical segregation, in my experience, women are not discouraged from entering the large animal field. Quite the contrary. At the vet school here, at least, they look desperately for applicants interested in large animal medicine. They might even get a slight edge in the competition. Because so many vet students go into small animal medicine, there is a shortage of large animal veterinarians. Out of the 87,946 positions held by US veterinarians in 2007, only a total of 12,972 deal with large animals (this number includes food animal exclusive, food animal predominant, mixed animal, and equine) (http://www.avma.org/reference/marketstats/usvets.asp). In my vet school interview, they asked with a great deal of interest if I had any experience with large animals, and though I had a little, when I stated that my focus was small animals, they seemed let down. But it is better to know what you want to go into, because vet schools want people who aren’t still trying to decide. The vertical segregation seems to be a result of personal choice rather than forced segregation, unlike with people-doctors. Large animal veterinarians actually make less than small animal vets (another switch that has come with time) because people will spend more on their pets (as they would for a child), whereas there are less farms, and less interest in that field (http://michaeldorf.org/2007/07/shortage-in-large-animal-veterinarians.html, http://www.bizjournal.com/content/article.php?id=432). The reason that men still statistically make more than women is because even most men go into small animal medicine—just the fact that the majority of the small number of large animal vets are male doesn’t mean the majority of males go into large animal medicine. The majority of all vet students tend to go for the small animal crowd, because that’s where the money is. In 2007, 38,974 of the 87,946 total vets worked exclusively with small animals in private practice (http://www.avma.org/reference/marketstats/usvets.asp). 47% of these vets were male, so women have already taken over the majority in small animal practice (although most are much less experienced in years than the males, for reasons already discussed), though 47% of nearly 39,000 is still more than the total (male and female) number of vets working with large animals. 14,435 of the 87,946 vets do not work in private practice—they work for the public or corporations; for example, over 6,000 vets work for colleges or universities (teaching hospitals and teaching vet students), others work for the government or uniformed services (the University of Tennessee offers a program where the Navy will pay for the tuition if students agree to spend their first 3 or so years as a licensed vet working in Naval bases working with the animals of those living on the base), and over 3,000 of these public/corporate vets work for industry (usually food industry, but not private practice). Males are the majority in these fields, but not by large margins. Most women are drawn to companion (small) animal medicine, as already discussed.
Is there horizontal segregation pushing men out of the veterinary field of medicine? Looking at statistics for medical doctors (people-doctors, if you will), in 2006, 27.8% of the 921,904 physicians in the US were female (http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/12912.html). This number is greatly improved from 7.6% female in 1970, but the percentage difference two years ago is still no where near where the percentage is for veterinary medicine. Perhaps there is horizontal segregation keeping women encouraged to work with animals and men with people. Some people do not believe veterinarians are “real” or serious doctors the way that medical physicians are, but the truth is that both MDs (medical doctor) and DVMs (doctor of veterinary medicine) learn the same biochemistry and medicine, only the latter learns how to apply this to multiple species. However, society constructs it so that MDs are taken more seriously, so perhaps that patriarch is encouraging men to be these serious doctors. The median salaries of medical physicians are also much higher than those of veterinary doctors. Depending on the physician’s focus (oncology, pediatrics, etc), the range for physician salaries is anywhere between $120,424 and $201,934 (http://www.payscale.com/research/US/People_with_Jobs_as_Physicians_%2F_Doctors/Salary). Men also may be gravitated more towards the jobs with the big money, and society constructs this as acceptable because men typically should be the moneymakers (according to our society as a whole). More stats with medical doctors should be left for those pursuing that field, but I wanted to show that perhaps another reason for the rise of women in veterinary medicine is horizontal segregation with men leaning more towards medical school than veterinary school.
Women have made remarkable steps in taking over veterinary medicine; however, there still seems to be a male-dominance in that men have simply moved on to higher-paying jobs that are taken more seriously—because typically society takes men more seriously than women. Women still have a long road to travel to truly reach equality—something I’ve learned this semester, because it’s not always so apparent that we’re not there yet unless you dig as deeply as this project requires. Women have made a dramatic increase in the medical doctor profession, as well, but it will still take more time for that number to reach even. Then again, perhaps it is personal choice. I was never discouraged from medical school—in fact, I was encouraged to go for it. It was my own passion for animals that led me to decide to take the smaller paycheck and the road to veterinary medicine. Perhaps women are more passionate about animals on average than men. Perhaps medical doctors are more inclined to want a position of power—something more typically characteristic of men—and veterinary doctors are more inclined to care about their patients than the money they make—something more characteristic of women. What women can do to help make people take veterinary medicine seriously is to work hard to keep up the high standards in the profession so that their clients all take them seriously and with respect. We can also help people take animals more seriously (and therefore animal medicine) by working to make better animal rights laws (lobbying, protesting, etc.). Also, let people know that their health would be on the line if a vet didn’t keep the cows they eat healthy. People should already know that, actually. And if they still don’t think a vet is a “real” doctor, ask them some tough biochemistry questions and watch their heads spin. After all, it takes just as much education and work to become an animal doctor as it does to become a people doctor.
Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
very well done -- when citing use the title of the publisher of the website instead of giving the weblink in text -- then have a list of sources at the end
Post a Comment