Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Career Project - Doctor of Veterinary Medicine
According to http://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Veterinarian/Salary/by_Gender, the median salary of female veterinarians is $62,612. Compare this to the male veterinarian median salary of $70,829. Why the $8,000 difference? Traditionally, men were the veterinarians, as men were traditionally the doctors. This tradition in the veterinary world has since been turned upside-down. Education Acts were passed in 1972 which prevented discrimination based on sex in college admissions, allowing more women to make their way to veterinary school (http://animalpetdoctor.homestead.com/historywomen.html). Most veterinary students today are women. For example, at Virginia-Maryland Regional College of Veterinary medicine, the Class of 2011 consisted of 90 students, 25 of which were male, and 65 out of the 90 students were female—slightly over 72% (www.vetmed.vt.edu). According to http://www.anapsid.org/vets/vetdemos.html, about 75% of the 9,276 veterinarian students in the nation (including all four years) are female. Fifty years ago, only 5% were female. What does this have to do with the salary difference? A lot, actually. Another factor that plays into average salaries is experience. Obviously, the longer a vet works, the higher the salary. From the same site (clicking on median based on experience rather than gender), vets working less than one year earn $55,316. Increase that to 1-4 years and the salary increases to $61,070; 5-9 years increases to $69,117; 10-19 years increases to $73,691; 20 years plus increases to $76,127. If women didn’t start taking over the majority until the 90s, that explains why most of them haven’t reached that seventy grand mark yet. Most haven’t been vets for more than 10 years, even. The large surge of women vets are just now coming into that high experience level. As with most things concerning women in the work world, things are still changing as new generations take over and have time to reach the top. These numbers should change dramatically in another generation.
Is there vertical segregation within the veterinary medicine field? Back when men dominated the profession, veterinarians primarily worked with large animals (horses, lifestock, and other farm animals). In order to maintain the health of large animals, one must get close enough to the animal and keep it steady enough to tranquilize or anesthetize it. It is more physical as a result. The medicine and biochemistry work is relatively similar to small animals, but handling the animals of a greater size takes a bit more physical effort, unless you compare a gentle horse to a temperamental rabid cat with claws. Statistically, men aim for more physical jobs than women. As of 2007, 83.9% of the food (large, cows mostly) animal exclusive and 82.6% of the food animal predominant veterinarians in private clinical practice are male. However, these numbers even out a bit in just equine medicine in private practice—56.5% of equine veterinarians in private practice are male (http://www.avma.org/reference/marketstats/usvets.asp). This could be explained by the stereotypical little girl’s wish to have a pony. Girls love horses, and they are trying to start taking over the majority of horse doctors, as well, with time. As of late, dogs and cats have become the focus of veterinary medicine as family pets have been treated as members of the family. Puppies and kittens do not require the physical effort to wrangle as cows and horses, so perhaps this is the reason men have strayed away from the field. Most women go into small animal medicine (dogs and cats, mostly, and the occasional rabbit), and most men go into large animal medicine where the job is still considered slightly physical (http://animalpetdoctor.homestead.com/historywomen.html). Where this information seems to suggest vertical segregation, in my experience, women are not discouraged from entering the large animal field. Quite the contrary. At the vet school here, at least, they look desperately for applicants interested in large animal medicine. They might even get a slight edge in the competition. Because so many vet students go into small animal medicine, there is a shortage of large animal veterinarians. Out of the 87,946 positions held by US veterinarians in 2007, only a total of 12,972 deal with large animals (this number includes food animal exclusive, food animal predominant, mixed animal, and equine) (http://www.avma.org/reference/marketstats/usvets.asp). In my vet school interview, they asked with a great deal of interest if I had any experience with large animals, and though I had a little, when I stated that my focus was small animals, they seemed let down. But it is better to know what you want to go into, because vet schools want people who aren’t still trying to decide. The vertical segregation seems to be a result of personal choice rather than forced segregation, unlike with people-doctors. Large animal veterinarians actually make less than small animal vets (another switch that has come with time) because people will spend more on their pets (as they would for a child), whereas there are less farms, and less interest in that field (http://michaeldorf.org/2007/07/shortage-in-large-animal-veterinarians.html, http://www.bizjournal.com/content/article.php?id=432). The reason that men still statistically make more than women is because even most men go into small animal medicine—just the fact that the majority of the small number of large animal vets are male doesn’t mean the majority of males go into large animal medicine. The majority of all vet students tend to go for the small animal crowd, because that’s where the money is. In 2007, 38,974 of the 87,946 total vets worked exclusively with small animals in private practice (http://www.avma.org/reference/marketstats/usvets.asp). 47% of these vets were male, so women have already taken over the majority in small animal practice (although most are much less experienced in years than the males, for reasons already discussed), though 47% of nearly 39,000 is still more than the total (male and female) number of vets working with large animals. 14,435 of the 87,946 vets do not work in private practice—they work for the public or corporations; for example, over 6,000 vets work for colleges or universities (teaching hospitals and teaching vet students), others work for the government or uniformed services (the University of Tennessee offers a program where the Navy will pay for the tuition if students agree to spend their first 3 or so years as a licensed vet working in Naval bases working with the animals of those living on the base), and over 3,000 of these public/corporate vets work for industry (usually food industry, but not private practice). Males are the majority in these fields, but not by large margins. Most women are drawn to companion (small) animal medicine, as already discussed.
Is there horizontal segregation pushing men out of the veterinary field of medicine? Looking at statistics for medical doctors (people-doctors, if you will), in 2006, 27.8% of the 921,904 physicians in the US were female (http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/12912.html). This number is greatly improved from 7.6% female in 1970, but the percentage difference two years ago is still no where near where the percentage is for veterinary medicine. Perhaps there is horizontal segregation keeping women encouraged to work with animals and men with people. Some people do not believe veterinarians are “real” or serious doctors the way that medical physicians are, but the truth is that both MDs (medical doctor) and DVMs (doctor of veterinary medicine) learn the same biochemistry and medicine, only the latter learns how to apply this to multiple species. However, society constructs it so that MDs are taken more seriously, so perhaps that patriarch is encouraging men to be these serious doctors. The median salaries of medical physicians are also much higher than those of veterinary doctors. Depending on the physician’s focus (oncology, pediatrics, etc), the range for physician salaries is anywhere between $120,424 and $201,934 (http://www.payscale.com/research/US/People_with_Jobs_as_Physicians_%2F_Doctors/Salary). Men also may be gravitated more towards the jobs with the big money, and society constructs this as acceptable because men typically should be the moneymakers (according to our society as a whole). More stats with medical doctors should be left for those pursuing that field, but I wanted to show that perhaps another reason for the rise of women in veterinary medicine is horizontal segregation with men leaning more towards medical school than veterinary school.
Women have made remarkable steps in taking over veterinary medicine; however, there still seems to be a male-dominance in that men have simply moved on to higher-paying jobs that are taken more seriously—because typically society takes men more seriously than women. Women still have a long road to travel to truly reach equality—something I’ve learned this semester, because it’s not always so apparent that we’re not there yet unless you dig as deeply as this project requires. Women have made a dramatic increase in the medical doctor profession, as well, but it will still take more time for that number to reach even. Then again, perhaps it is personal choice. I was never discouraged from medical school—in fact, I was encouraged to go for it. It was my own passion for animals that led me to decide to take the smaller paycheck and the road to veterinary medicine. Perhaps women are more passionate about animals on average than men. Perhaps medical doctors are more inclined to want a position of power—something more typically characteristic of men—and veterinary doctors are more inclined to care about their patients than the money they make—something more characteristic of women. What women can do to help make people take veterinary medicine seriously is to work hard to keep up the high standards in the profession so that their clients all take them seriously and with respect. We can also help people take animals more seriously (and therefore animal medicine) by working to make better animal rights laws (lobbying, protesting, etc.). Also, let people know that their health would be on the line if a vet didn’t keep the cows they eat healthy. People should already know that, actually. And if they still don’t think a vet is a “real” doctor, ask them some tough biochemistry questions and watch their heads spin. After all, it takes just as much education and work to become an animal doctor as it does to become a people doctor.
Thursday, April 24, 2008
Activity 11: Women's Issues in the 2008 Presidential Election
Let’s start with the white male, since white male-ness has had the incumbency for the entirety of our nation’s existence. Republican candidate John McCain. On his website, under issues, he lists one as “Human Dignity and the Sanctity of Life.” This is the issue in which we can find his ideas that will affect women. One of his focuses will be to overturn Roe v. Wade and return the abortion issue to the state governments. McCain strongly opposes abortion, and states that the “fight for life” (in other words, fight to end abortion) will “be one of courage and compassion—the courage of a pregnant mother to bring her child into the world and the compassion of civil society to meet her needs and those of her unborn baby.” He proposes an alternative to abortion: promoting adoption as the first option for struggling pregnant women. Well, I support adoption before abortion, too, but then again, I haven’t been put in that situation, so I can’t tell women what they can and cannot do to with their own bodies, either. I don’t know that anyone can really tell women, or anyone for that matter, what they can and cannot do to themselves.
Another issue McCain addresses is that of marriage: McCain believes that marriage is a “union between one man and one woman,” and that it is “only this definition sufficiently recognizes the vital and unique role played by mothers and fathers in the raising of children, and the role of the family in shaping, stabilizing, and strengthening communities and out nation.” He’s not crazy like Bush was though, because he believes that this, too, should be up to the state governments, so chances are he’s not going to push that amendment that Bush wanted. Still, his views on what “family” and “marriage” should be are reminiscent of the classic patriarch.
Let’s check out the Democrats. Hilary Clinton deems herself as “a champion for women.” Obviously, if elected, she would be the first woman president. She was at the 1995 UN conference in Beijing and said, “women’s rights are human rights.” Because women only earn 77% of what men earn in our country, she wants to strengthen equal pay laws and end pay disparities between men and women. She introduced the Paycheck Fairness Act to strengthen penalties for wage discrimination. She seeks to empower women in business by helping them start their own businesses. Woo. Girl Power, corporate style.
On the abortion issue, she wants to protect Roe v. Wade and women’s right to choose, as well as expand access to family planning services (especially for low-income women). She supports the Prevention First Act, which requires health insurance companies to cover contraception.
And now for Barack Obama. Like Hilary, his website shows that women only make 77 cents to every male earned dollar, and he wants to pass the Fair Pay Act to ensure that women receive equal pay for equal work. He also states that he will work to overturn the Supreme Court’s recent ruling that “curtails racial minorities’ and women’s ability to challenge pay discrimination.” Both democrats seek this equality for women.
Obama proposes are a lot of tax breaks for working families, and supports fatherhood and families. He wants a Responsible Fatherhood and Healthy Families Act to remove some of the government penalties on married families and crack down on men who avoid paying child support. He also wants to fund support for fathers and their families, and he supports domestic violence prevention efforts. From a Women’s Studies prospective, I’m a little torn on this one. On one end, he’s helping women by supporting prevention of domestic violence and putting the smack-down on some dead-beat dads who won’t help support their children. On the other hand, there seems to be a slight support for the patriarch, and what exactly defines family? Does this mean that family should be man and woman? The republican view? It’s noble to want to help a child receive love and support from both parents, but what about homosexual families? I need more specific information on this. Also, I can’t find information on the marriage issue with the democrats. At least not on their websites. What alternative do homosexuals have to McCain’s definition?
Well, there you have it. Women’s issues in the presidential election. But please, check out the education, along with other issues, before you vote! I hate it when people vote based on only 1 or 2 issues, and negate the rest of them, and then our education system and economy are screwed up.
Oh, and I’m joining the patriarch. I’m engaged. Good news is, he’s okay with doing laundry and cleaning, mostly because I hate it. Yay role reversal!
Tuesday, April 22, 2008
Activity 10: Is Veterinary Medicine Going Pink Collar?
Down to business: salaries. After some google searching and further digging into vet sites, I finally found a breakdown by gender. The last four years have made me a google-master. According to http://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Veterinarian/Salary/by_Gender, the median salary of female veterinarians (holla!) is $62,612. Compare this to the male veterinarian median salary of $70,829. Damn. What I could do with an extra $8,000 a year… Get Scout a little puppy sister. Replace those nice red shoes that Scout ate the other day. Get a new car since mine is singing its swan song. I would like a hybrid, in the spirit of green week. Sigh. I think this requires more digging.
So why the $8,000 difference? Well, traditionally, men were the veterinarians, as men were traditionally the doctors. (Both are doctors, but vets are the doctors that can treat multiple species and help patients that cannot tell them their symptoms or what is wrong with them. Vets are doctors and scientists all rolled into one skilled package.) Well, tradition in the veterinary world has been turned upside-down. Most veterinary students today are women. Take the very school I’m trying to fight my way into for example: The Veterinary Medicine Class of 2011 consisted of 90 students, 25 of which were male. Unless I can’t do kindergarten math (okay, I was in an advanced kindergarten class), that makes 65 out of the 90 students female—slightly over 72%. Niice. So THAT’s why they want guys to apply… That info can be found at www.vetmed.vt.edu. Check out the DVM program, and the hoops I’ve been jumping through to get in. According to http://www.anapsid.org/vets/vetdemos.html, about 75% of the 9,276 veterinarian students in the nation (that’s including all four years) are female. Fifty years ago, only 5% were female. That’s quite a jump. So what does this have to do with the salary difference? A lot, actually. Another factor that plays into average salaries is experience. Obviously, the longer a vet works, the higher the salary (aren’t most jobs like that?). Let me get you some numbers to play with. From the same useful site (I clicked median based on experience rather than gender this time), vets working less than one year earn $55,316. Increase that to 1-4 years and you increase the salary to $61,070; 5-9 years increases to $69,117; 10-19 years increases to $73,691; 20 years plus increases to $76,127. If women didn’t start taking over the majority until the 90s, that explains why most of them haven’t reached that seventy grand mark yet. Most haven’t been vets for more than 10 years, even. The large surge of women vets are just now coming into that high experience level. As with most things concerning women in the work world, things are still changing as new generations take over and have time to reach the top. We’ll see what these numbers say when I’m at that seventy grand mark.
Is there vertical segregation within the veterinary medicine field? Well, back when men dominated the profession, veterinarians primarily worked with large animals. You know, horses, lifestock, and other farm animals. It was more physical as a result. You know how men like their physical jobs (statistically). As of late, dogs and cats have become the focus as family pets have been treated as members of the family (as they should be!). Puppies and kittens do not require the physical effort to wrangle as cows and horses (although some cats… it sure takes some agility sometimes), so perhaps this is the reason men have strayed away from the field. Most women go into small animal medicine (dogs and cats, mostly, and the occasional rabbit), and most men go into large animal medicine where the job is still considered slightly physical (http://animalpetdoctor.homestead.com/historywomen.html). Where this information seems to suggest vertical segregation, in my experience, women are not discouraged from entering the large animal field. Quite the contrary. At the vet school here, at least, they look desperately for applicants interested in large animal medicine. They might even get a slight edge in the competition. Because so many vet students go into small animal medicine, there is a shortage of large animal veterinarians. I know in my interview, they asked with a great deal of interest if I had any experience with large animals, and though I had a little, when I stated that my focus was small animals, they seemed let down. At least I know what I want. Those who say, “I don’t know what I want to go into” don’t get in at all. The vertical segregation seems to be a result of personal choice rather than forced segregation, unlike with people-doctors. Yet another reason I like my future profession more. I’d have more concrete numbers for this, but AVMA makes you pay for their later statistics. What part of poor college student trying to be an even more poor vet student don’t they get? Speaking of money, or lack there of, large animal veterinarians actually make less than small animal vets (another switch that has come with time) because people will spend more on their pets (as they would for a child), whereas there are less farms, and less interest in that field (http://michaeldorf.org/2007/07/shortage-in-large-animal-veterinarians.html, http://www.bizjournal.com/content/article.php?id=432). The reason that men still statistically make more than women is because even most men go into small animal medicine—just the fact that the majority of the small number of large animal vets are male doesn’t mean the majority of males go into large animal medicine. The majority of all vet students tend to go for the small animal crowd, because that’s where the money is. Heaven knows I’ve spent more on my dog than myself this past year. She’s my baby (I haven’t told her she’s adopted yet).
Friday, April 18, 2008
Extra Credit: Born Into Brothels
Zana also continues to find a school for Avijit, saying he is talented and needs help before he goes down wrong path. However, Avijit says he doesn’t want to go to the school if they put him back two grades. Another boy wants to go, anyway. One of the girl’s family won’t let her go to school because it’s a Thursday and her mother died on a Thursday. But it’s the last day to be able to go. She gets to go thanks to Zana. Avajit finally gets his passport and is excited to go to Amsterdam. He feels like taking pictures again, and loses his apathy. He then choses to go to school. Unfortunately, his hash-smoking father won’t let his son go to school. One girl was removed from school by her mother, another girl removed herself, another girl ran away form home to go to school, and other girl’s aunt wouldn’t let her leave the brothel. One boy is still in school. Kochi, a girl, is still in school and happy. A few successes in a world of hopelessness.
One connection to this class is obvious: the way the women are treated as sexual objects, and the way the young girls are forced into the “profession” and not expected to make it as anything more than whores. The women are beated and even killed by their pimps and husbands. They have no rights. The kids and mothers were invited to the exhibition of their photos, but one boy says his mom can’t come because she has to cook. Even the children who dream of leaving this ugly lifestyle still have expectations of their mothers fitting only one role. It’s really sad.
One little girl says “they say it won’t be long” until she “joins the line,” meaning she’ll work as a prostitute. This shocks me because she’s like ten years old! My God, these poor children are being robbed of their childhood and innocence. They are treated horribly, and their parents cuss at them and force them to be practically be slaves. One small boy is even chained. It’s horrible. Another thing that pissed me off is that the zoo animals are underfed and abused (fed plastic bags). Fucking assholes. There’s no respect for live at all here—no respect for the children or animals. I really want to know why don’t they put pants on some of the smaller kids… It’s really sad. One girl thinks she’ll have to end up taking care of her little sister, which would prevent her from going to school and escaping the brothel. Gosh, this is sad. One kid’s mother died when her pimp set her kitchen on fire. What a dickhead. There’s no police involvement, no justice. One poor boy said he “used to want to be a doctor, then an artist… there is nothing called ‘hope’ in my future.” This is so sad. These children want so badly to be something else, but feel trapped in the brothels. Zana helps some of them get into schools, but only a few of them remain there. The brothel sucks them back in. At least a few of them were able to remain in school and be happy for once in their lives, but gosh, what about the rest? It’s so sad that they are forced to continue the vicious cycle of the brothel life…
Friday, April 11, 2008
CRJ-7: Move Over, Interracial Marriage. America's Got a New Target to Pick On
So let’s pick out some of Sprigg’s more “intelligent” arguments. By intelligent, I mean about as intelligent as President Bush writing his own speeches. “If love and companionship were sufficient to define marriage, then there would be no reason to deny ‘marriage’ to unions of a child and an adult, or an adult child and his or her aging parent…” Are you serious? OBVIOUSLY the question about “isn’t love enough” was not referring to pedophilia or incest. It refers to love between two of-age adults that are not related. I’m sure Sprigg was aware of this, as it’s friggin obvious that’s what people mean when they refer to the love between two people who wish to spend their lives together. He opted for the high road: the cop out. Classy, Sprigg. Homosexuals do not condone or support in any way the sexual abuse of children, or the sexual interactions between family members, any more than heterosexuals do. Kurdek shows in his study that homosexual couples are not that different than heterosexuals in a relationship. Really, they’re not that different from heterosexuals at all except who they are attracted to. It’s not like they’re criminals or mentally inept. You don’t have to treat them as such. Ignorant… Oh, but Sprigg says that they have the right to marry.. as long as they marry the opposite sex—someone they don’t love. That’s great. A love-less marriage. Because every kid dreams of coming home to his/her parents hating each other and screaming. That’s a great environment for kids. Let that unhappy home fester for a while long enough, and you’ve got yourself an abuse case. Screaming turns to fighting, which turns to someone letting loose an elbow or two. And the kid gets stuck in the middle.
Speaking of kids, Sprigg states, without evidence, that same-sex marriage “will open the door to homosexual adoption, which will simply lead to more children suffering the negative consequences of growing up without both a mother and a father.” Well, Sprigg, sometimes one is enough. Single parents are able to raise happy and successful children all the time. I’ve met kids who have had only one parent. They turned out fine. Sometimes one is better than two that hate each other. But children of homosexual couples wouldn’t only have one. They’d have two. Two parents that love them unconditionally. That’s what every child wants. That’s what every child needs. There’s enough gender expectations pushed on kids from society that lacking male or female roles in the home probably won’t change the outcome of the child’s gender. The children are going to be who they are. I think I’ve even heard somewhere that children of homosexual parents usually turn out exactly how society wanted them to—their expected gender and sexual preference of heterosexual. The only negative consequence that these children have to face is the judgment bestowed upon them by the ignorant, closed-minded people like Sprigg. Sprigg, in writing his discriminating arguments, is adding to the suffering, the teasing, and the judgment that these kids will have to face. If people could just see how ignorant they are being, and how ridiculous all this discrimination is, then we can negate this one and only negative consequence.
Sprigg also tries to negate that discrimination against homosexual couples is the new discrimination against interracial couples. He again failed to make any sense. “Laws against interracial marriage…served only the purpose of preserving a social system of racial segregation.” Um, isn’t this the same thing? Isn’t our social system generally against homosexuality, especially same-sex marriage? And aren’t the laws against is preserving that social system? Isn’t marriage an institution created by man? Isn’t that a social system? Are we not discriminating against a certain group of people to preserve a man-made social institution?? Marriage may pre-date the United States, but it does not pre-date man. It is still a social institution. Sprigg admits that discriminating against interracial marriage was unworthy, even though, at the time, it challenged the social system. This really is the same thing, dude. You’re just too closed-minded to see anything other than what makes you right. Heaven forbid you could be wrong about something.
Here’s a good one: “Social Security survivor benefits were designed to recognize the non-monetary contribution made to by a family by the homemaking and child-rearing activities of a wife and mother, and to ensure that a woman and her children would not become destitute if the husband and father were to die…. Very few homosexual couples organize their lives along the lines of such a ‘traditional’ division of labor and roles.” Um, dude, neither do most heterosexual couples, nowadays. If that quote doesn’t scream, “Woman belongs in the kitchen popping out babies while the husband brings home the bacon,” I don’t know what does. It’s heavily based on an outdated patriarch. Women are very productive and successful, and we can get our own bacon, thank you very much. Actually, I prefer turkey or soy. I’m not big on the red meat. I see their faces, and remember that I have always wanted a pet pig. My point remains, that I don’t need a man to support me. I don’t cook and clean my house everyday so my man can come home to the smell of his dinner waiting for him. And I definitely am not a walking baby machine. So, how do you argue that your point is not outdated when you support your point with an outdated social construct? Yeaaah, I got you there, don’t I?
I kinda feel like homosexual marriage is the skinny little 6th grader, and America's the 8th grade bully that wants his lunch money... There's no reason to pick on him, they just have nothing better to do than assert their dominance.
Friday, April 4, 2008
CRJ-6: Bringing It All Together
Women are supposed to be feminine; feminine should be defined as emotional, passive, and dependent. At least that’s what the book says. Of course there are plenty of independent women out there. Then again, look at advertisements, and women are depicted similarly to this book description: passive, vulnerable, and sexually available for her man. She is an object for male sexual gratification. Starting to see the link? Our very media is constructing our societal expectations of women. Some men take it too far. They begin to think that women really are objects whose sole purpose is to please men sexually, and to be inferior to strong, dominant men. Men who want to prove that they aren’t “sissies.” Men who want to show the world their dominance, their power, their control, and their strength. Their masculinity. Rape is an action of dominance more so than one of sexual gratification.
Personally, anyone ignorant enough to believe that women are objects, that women are subservient to men, or that women should give a man sexual gratification whenever the hell he wants it isn’t a real man. It seems to me that someone who has to go to such disgusting lengths to show off his masculinity, dominion, and power is really just completely insecure in his masculinity. He takes control by force to prove to the world he’s not a sissy because he’s desperately trying to prove it to himself. Don’t misunderstand me: there is not one picoliter of pity in my tone here. If you’re that insecure about your masculinity, join the fight to end these retarded social constructs and to end the senseless violence. Don’t add to it. Sexual violence is disgustingly senseless. It doesn’t prove you’re a man. It proves you’re quite less than a man. It proves that you’re quite less than human.
So here’s our problem: we’ve got society telling us what men and women should be like (gender construct), and anything that strays from this is discriminated against. This discrimination instills the fear to prove we’re what we should be. The media doesn’t help as it is constantly in our faces exaggerating these gender constructs in a sexual manner, because sex is the only thing that sells, apparently. So now we’ve got to prove we are what we should be sexually. This leads to further sexual and gender identity discrimination. It also leads to the idea that men should have access to women when they want—that sex is obligatory for women. This is held up by the patriarch on which our society was founded. Again, if anything challenges the social norm, all hell breaks loose, and there is hell to pay. This leads to violence. That is really one convoluted and screwed up society pretzel. The only way to stop the violence, it seems, is to change society’s expectations. Change society’s gender constructions, gender ideals, and even sexual expectations. Eliminate the discrimination against those who challenge the norm. Accept anomalies. Punish the ones that discriminate, not the victims.
Maybe Scout’s right. Maybe we should just glance over that eighth amendment when it comes to sexual violence. Is it really cruel and unusual to take away the weapon used in a violent crime?
Thursday, April 3, 2008
Activity 9: Canine Wisdom--Scout's Solution to Violence Against Women
I pulled some statistics on violence against women from the book. The intention was to show these to four people and get their responses… hopefully without screwing them all up psychologically.
The Stats:
-A sexual assault (including rape) occurs about every 2 minutes.
-Approximately 56 women are victimized in some way by an intimate partner every hour.
-1 in 5 high school girls in the US reported being abused physically and/or sexually by a boyfriend.
-50 to 80% of teenagers reported knowing others in violent relationships.
-13% of female college students in 2000 had been stalked that school year and 4 of 5 women knew their stalkers.
-Around the world, 1 in 3 women are beaten, coerced into sex, and otherwise abused.
-95% of reported sexual assaults are against women.
-half of all females raped are under 18 years old; about 1/5 are under 12.
-1 in 3 women will experience sexual assault (including rape) in her lifetime.
-1 in 4 college women experience sexual violence.
-9 in 10 female college students who had been sexually assaulted (more than a third of the female student population) and raped (10%) knew her offender.
-70 to 80% of campus rapes generally involve alcohol or other drugs (usually alcohol).
-10 to 14% of married women in the
Notice I’m not touching the section on domestic violence involving children witnessing it or being victims of it. Sorry. That’s too close to home.
I’ve chosen a lot of statistics that involve college students, since that’s what most of my friends and I are. It settles in a bit deeper that way. Like, damn, that could be me. Or my best friend. Or my sister. It makes us a bit more angry at it, like we should be. It’s disgusting, isn’t it?
My first interviewee was my male friend. His reaction to the statistics was of shock. He didn’t realize the numbers could ever be so high, and he said it didn’t seam real. He had no stories to share as he said he hadn’t known any of his personal friends who had been abused. He attributed this to why he was so shocked. When asked what could be the cause of violence against women, he guessed at the following: jealousy, men feeling insecure, or maybe rage against something like work. He never guessed that our very social construct of gender was perhaps the culprit. He never mentioned male dominance, which is usually what rapists want—dominance. He wasn’t sure as to what could be done to stop the violence. He said, “it’s sad, but a lot of guts scoff or ignore commercials about violence against women. There has to be a much more vigorous or engaging awareness program.” As to what would be more vigorous or engaging, he did not specify. He also added, “increasing punishment really wouldn’t [work], because women would start to use that and start lying. Other options would lead to abuse of the law or each other to a greater degree.” Ouch, dude. He seems more worried about the few women who take advantage of the punishment for rape and falsely accuse men than the tragically high numbers of women who are indeed sexually abused but never see justice for it. Sigh. Men are brainwashed. Maybe this is why women have to insist that they weren’t wearing provocative clothes or weren’t “asking for it."
My second interviewee was my boyfriend. Let’s get the men’s answers out of the way so I can end the assignment with less brainwashed people. I have faith in my boy, though. Let’s see if his answers are better than my friend’s. His reaction to the statistics was again of shock. The numbers were higher than he had thought. Again, no stories to tell. I’m wondering if that’s even a good idea to ask people, especially as I prepare to interview women. Justin’s estimated cause for the violence is a “combination of things: sometimes it’s men being douchebags, and other times women can lead themselves into it. That statistic they don’t know is how many women in abusive relationships stay with or take the guy back.” Okay, valid as that is, where do the women go? Sometimes they stay because they don’t know where else they can go. I’d say for that, women’s shelters need to make themselves more noticed. Women need to know that there is always somewhere safe for them to run to. He added, “maybe some men want to be in control and dominate women.” Right on target. He’s so smart. When asked how could violence against women be stopped, he began with a joke, suggesting chemical castration for the abusers, followed by a “just kidding.” He then suggested that the penal system should be stronger, with heavier punishments for sexual assaults and violence. As he went on, he said that maybe that chemical castration joke wasn’t such a joke. For those who rape and abuse young children (referring to the statistic of under 12 years of age), those guys really should get their “balls chopped off.” And, as he said it, that’s a guy saying that.
Girls are hard to find during class hours. I asked my dog, who is a girl, what she thought about rapists. She proceeded to grab a long loofa-dog toy (phallic representation, perhaps?) and bit it, over and over, making it squeak. Scout (the dog) says rapists should have their penises bitten off? I always knew dogs were intelligent. Or she just wants to play, and really can’t understand English, other than the usual favorite words (cookie, outside, etc).
The reason finding the girls to interview was so hard was because I wanted to be careful who I brought this up to. I didn’t want to bring up any horrific memories to those either sensitive to it or I have known to have had bad experiences. It may be bad for my assignment in this class, but I feel better not causing that emotional trauma to return.
My female friend reacted to the statistics with an outrage, saying, “they’re ridiculous… it makes me worry for my friends and residents.” She said that she did have stories about people she knows, but she did not feel comfortable sharing them. She also had no idea as to what the cause for the violence could be, which leads me to think that she just can’t come up with anything that makes the violence make any sense. Personally, that’s wise, because this violence is senseless. Her solution was the following: “make people more aware of the kinds of choices they are making and the situations they put themselves in and the people they spend their time with and how to protect themselves.” She’s on the right track. If people are educated, they will know what warning signs to look for and know where they can go or what they can do to get themselves out of the situation. Unfortunately, some of these attacks are unexpected. What do we do, then?
My lab partner, who is female, gasped when she saw the statistics. She said they were really surprising. She knew that violence against women was a problem, but had no idea how often it occurred. She said that she has had a stalker here at Tech before, and that it was very scary. She does not know anyone in a violent relationship. She can also see that these statistics are surprising because people don’t necessarily tell you when they’ve experienced these things, so you don’t really hear about it much from the people you know. She also says that this problem is too overlooked on campuses. Her solution, without even being asked for one yet (I got all this from asking for her reaction and she’s answering everything before I ask!), was to increase awareness. Same as my other female friend. I suppose females think alike there. It’s true, though. Awareness should be increased and women need to know how to prepare themselves to avoid such experiences. I finally got to ask her what she thinks causes violence against women, to which she replied, “temper problems? Anger? If a man never had a good female figure in his life, then it’s harder for them to respect anyone that comes into his life that’s a female.” So it stems from childhood, eh? Actually, that’s probably the most accurate assumption yet. Except that I think that the father figure also affects this. If a man has a good male role model to teach him how he should treat women, then I think the guy will turn out alright. If a man has a good mother figure who shows him that women are good people, too, I think the man would have a greater respect for women. It’s up to the parents to not screw up, basically. So the moral of the story is, increase awareness and teach your kids good morals. And Scout still says to chomp hard on the penis of a rapist. Good dog.
Friday, March 28, 2008
Extra Credit: Vera Drake
In the beginning of the movie, there is a rape scene, showing the man’s feeling that he should have sexual dominance over the young woman. This girl seeks help from male doctors who actually seem to blame her for being raped, calling into question her mental state. They don’t ever seem to care that she was raped, which is outrageous, but it shows how the men in the 1950s viewed women. Women were below men. Speaking of which, women also weren’t allowed to choose what happened to their bodies when pregnancy was involved (or sex, for that matter). Vera's very son reacts harshly saying that his mother let him down. This shows that he was socialized in a world where women should not have this choice over their bodies. Even Vera's sister-in-law throws an emotional fit about not wanting to ever see Vera to her husband. She, too, has been socialized to believe that women should not have the right to choose.
My initial response to the movie was this: OMG, is that Umbridge??? It IS!! Now throughout the movie I hear that annoying squeaky laugh. Seriously, though, the movie starts eliciting a speechless expression from me almost immediately. Starting with what looks like rape, then jumping to a quickie boiling soapy water death bath for the fetus. I think my uterus hurts. Ow. My respect for men in the 1950s has plummeted after watching both the rape and the male doctors’ reactions to it. Honestly I think all the excessive smoking would solve the problem of all these unwanted pregnancies. Vera's son is quick to turn on his own mother for the abortion issue, which only adds to my dislike for most of the males in the movie. The guy who calls the abortions one of the most serious offenses is harsh in my post-Roe v. Wade eyes. The "extreme seriousness of her crime" was just helping troubled women choose what happened to their bodies. Granted, yes, the fetuses were killed and that's a sad subject, but in the case where the women were raped, seriously, it's not that unreasonable. This society takes no consideration in the women's mental or physical well being. I have to say, though, the technology for these procedures was dicey in this time period. Perhaps the likelihood of the women's death did play a role in society's position on it, but still judging by the way they treated the girl who was raped, I have to doubt they cared that much.
CRJ-5: The Price of Ignorant Lawmakers
Chapter 6 of the text brings up a point that many educated Americans, and a lot more people abroad, already know: our current administration is led by a bunch of dufuses, the lead dufus, of course, being W himself. Although, considering he was elected not once, but twice, into the White House, it doesn’t speak highly of the intelligence of the general American population. Don’t look at me, dude. I voted against the dufus when he was re-elected, and I was too young to vote the first time he was elected (though even then I knew Gore was the better choice!).
My point is, the administration has its bass-ackwards (switch the b) policies affecting the health of not just Americans, but people across the globe, especially Africa. Narrow-minded and ignorant, the administration has continued to push for ineffective policies even though scientists have given them more than enough evidence showing that the current policies aren’t working, and that the bills that the administration has opposed would actually work better (Clean Air bill, anyone? Oh, right. The administration would rather have the Clean Skies act that didn’t hold a candle to it. How does that make sense?). Not just affecting the very air we breathe, but also reproductive health, the administration continues its medieval policies based on their religion (what happened to separation of church and state?), pushing abstinence-only programs that have shown time after time to be, to quote the book, “ineffective in preventing sexual activity and disease transmission” (309). You know, my favorite professor always said that the definition of crazy is to do the same thing over and over and expect a different result. I’d say that Bush has gone pretty bonkers according to this definition. It’s okay though, he’s got money and insurance to get him through it. Listen to reason, dude. Everyone knows it doesn’t work here, and it doesn’t work in Africa. You know what does work? Edu-freaking-cation. Accept the fact that people are going to be sexual. Teach them about protecting themselves (condoms are not the devil incarnate). Provide them with such protection (and I don’t mean throw a Bible at them!!).
Reproductive choice (abortion, mostly) is a rather sticky subject. You know I’m not for the bible-hugging policies, but I do value life. That said, I’m really torn on this subject. I’ve known people who have had abortions, and I can see why they did. They were young, and having a child at that stage in their life would have meant sacrificing their education, which in turn would have meant sacrificing the ability to get a decent-paying job, and the poverty cycle would just continue from there. It wouldn’t have been a good environment for the kid. Some of those girls I once knew are now becoming college graduates soon. Good for them… I don’t know what it must feel like, though. I’ve never been in their shoes, thank God. I keep thinking of the cost. That fetus was alive… I’d like to think if it had been me, I would have found a stable couple to adopt it. I realize that’s a bit naïve, and the numbers of children growing up in orphanages are pretty sad. That’s not a great environment, either. It’s touchy. I stick to my to-each-her-own policy, because I wouldn’t want someone else to make that decision for me, so I won’t make that decision for someone else. If I didn’t dislike politics so much… No, I will never go into politics, sorry. But they should probably read my blog.
I’m all for birth-control. Women should have that right to choose to be sexual without having a family if they do not wish to have one. The problem is economic. Many women can’t afford birth control, and the administration doesn’t seem to care, because it’s free to abstain. Why should a married woman have to abstain, anyway, even according to the religious views? Is that to say that poverty-stricken people don’t have the right to embrace their sexual natures? Wow, that is arrogant. Those with lower incomes are the most desperate for birth control because they cannot afford to support a large brood of kids before stabilizing themselves financially. And yet, the administration continues to make birth control difficult. However, it will help you get sterilized. There’s no option of ‘I’ll be safe from having kids for a few years while I get my economic situation stabile, then I’ll choose to have a child or two.’ There’s only the option of have a bunch of babies that you can’t afford, or don’t reproduce at all. I guess there’s always the hope that the tube-tying ends up like my mom’s.
This is why everyone is so interested in this coming election. Save us from the idiotic policies from the last seven-plus years!! (and thank God Huckabee’s out. No pun intended. Maybe a little pun.)
Friday, March 21, 2008
Activity 8: When a Size 4 is Considered Too Fat. Say Wha?
I think I just threw up a little… I’m not entirely sure whether it was out of disgust for the advertising media, or because my body just said, “Oh GOD! I’m not a stick figure!!! QUICK! EXPELL THE GIRL SCOUT COOKIE!” Not the girl scout cookie!!! I love those! …yeah, it was out of disgust, and not for the cookie.
The video “Killing Us Softly” (part trois) shows the bigger effect of the advertising media to those who couldn’t already see it. Honestly, how blind do you have to be… nevermind. Anyone who’s seen “America’s Next Top Model” knows the “plus size” girl, who is actually still skinnier than the average woman, never wins. She’s there to make Tyra Banks feel better about herself as she tells the girls that the modeling industry will tell even the skinniest girl on the show that she’ll need to lose weight. Models are essential to the advertising world—the abnormally skinny, supposedly flawless girl that we all should strive to be, but inevitably cannot. Apparently, this is the only way to sell crap. This not only makes girls’ self-esteem plummet to hell, but it makes it okay for guys to exacerbate it by telling us we’re too fat to be considered attractive.
Advertisements sell more than the crap they’re trying to make money on. They sell impossibility, and the need to strive for it. Not just strive, but practically (and sometimes literally) kill yourself for it. The flawless look of abnormally thin, freakishly tall, and yet somehow with decent cleavage… The advertising media can blame themselves for the sickeningly large number of eating disorders. It’s really sad when even I sometimes look at my stomach and pout, wishing I’d feel better about myself in a bikini. Then rationality hits and I’m like, dude, I’m freaking only 120 pounds! Why do I feel fat?!? Oh, yeah, it’s because I weigh 20 pounds more than every girl I see in advertisements. That means I am 20 pounds overweight. I won’t be desirable until I lose 20 pounds. Ouch.
Advertisements also sell the debasement of women. They sell the social expectations for women to be vulnerable, to be sexual objects for men, and to be less powerful than men. Some of the advertisements shown in the video almost seemed to make potential rape just fine, and even romantic. It showed involuntary sex as voluntary, but she’s just making it sexy by saying no. She’s asking for it. Women aren’t people anymore, they’re objects for male gratification. And, of course, the men in advertisements always look powerful. Any powerful looking woman in an ad looks masculine, showing that only masculinity can be powerful. To be feminine is to be vulnerable. To be a woman is to be socially virginal, but sexually available for her man. That just makes it okay to call women whores when it is known that they’ve had sex, but to encourage males to do the same. Gag. Aw, man, not the other cookie… These things are expensive…
Here’s our dilemma. We have to be skinny, tall, and virginal to everyone socially. But then we have to be erotic and sexy whenever our men want us to be. We also have to have boobs, while still remaining skinny. Basically, we all need plastic surgeons to enhance our boobs, remove any trace of fat, get rid of wrinkles, lengthen our femurs, and to reinstate our virginity, on a daily basis. No wonder advertisements think young attractive women are gold-diggers. How do you think they got that attractive? Someone has to pay for it. God messed up pretty bad if all women are so far from attractive naturally. Or, we’re all brainwashed by the media.
Not to mention that all of this sexuality is based on heterosexuality. Anything that involves two girls is meant for a man’s heterosexual pleasure, so even that doesn’t count as homosexual. Don’t get me started on that, though. There are enough problems with the media to go on.
The Dove videos support everything I’ve been ranting about. From very young childhood, when we play with anatomically impossible Barbie or watch TV with the parents and see the commercials, the media’s expectation of beauty is immediately impressed upon us. Some girls get hit with the extremes of this so fast that five-year-olds are wearing make-up and being paraded around as sexual objects. It’s disgusting. And then we see that the impeccably beautiful women we see in these ads aren’t even that impeccably pretty. A lot of models are average looking women blended with the art of computer retouching. So these images that we kill ourselves to achieve don’t even exist. What we all need is a computer program embedded in us that projects a retouched version of ourselves to the world. Then we’ll be okay.
I tried to find a commercial that I actually liked to see if it was adding to the brainwashing. The make-up commercials and beer commercials are obvious in their attempt to make you think that women should be a certain way. I wanted to see something with a more subtle effect. I love the dancing lizards in the Sobe Life Water commercial. I could care less for Naomi Campbell, though. Her half-assed dancing was pretty pointless and took away from the hilarity of the dancing lizards. But, still, the company felt it necessary to put a supermodel in the commercial to show people that famous, beautiful people drink this product, so if you want to look like a supermodel, you should, too. If you go to http://www.thrillicious.com and look at the “episodes” (there are two of them), you can see the preliminary commercials that led to the anticipated Super Bowl ad that is the dancing lizards and Naomi Campbell trying to be as cool as the animated lizards. In episode 2, the lizards are talking about asking Naomi out, but are thwarted by the fact that she’s too good for them, because they are, well, lizards. In the end, they reveal that another lizard was able to marry a human woman, but only because she looked like “Richard Nixon.” A picture of a manly looking woman with a lizard is shown, which suggests that masculine women are not as good as the feminine perfection that is a supermodel. Masculine women are so unattractive, in fact, that even lizards can get them. Actually, the lizard probably gets her because no man wanted her. Men want supermodels. I laughed at this commercial, only to shut myself up and realize I’m only adding to the discrimination against masculine-looking women. Oops. The media has gotten me, too. These kinds of commercials are more subtle and implant femininity vs. masculinity and their respective levels of attractiveness in a way that isn’t seen at first. It’s brilliant brainwashing, actually, especially for those of us who try to resist the sexy ads. Argh. The media wins again. I should go eat a piece of lettuce in lieu of my cookie because I have more body fat than that anorexic chick on ANTM. Screw that; bring on the Thin Mint. Oooh man, even my cookie has the word thin in it. It never ends!!!
Friday, February 29, 2008
Activity 7: Why I'm Glad I Don't Have a Penis
Ah, so men are the root of all of society’s problems. Ha, I’m kidding (kind of), but perhaps masculinity in the way that society has constructed it is. Men keep each other in constant awareness of their masculinity. Anything that goes against the gender norms of “manliness” is immediately attacked, and usually by other men, because for some reason they need the approval of each other. These norms include violence, not showing emotion (being “tough”), and even walking a certain way, dressing a certain way, and treating women a certain way. That last one may explain some of the douchebagery of young adult men and their obsession with loveless sex. Any deviance form these norms leave a man open to ridicule, name-calling (sissy, the f-word that I don’t use [and it doesn’t rhyme with duck, because I use that one], etc), and even violence. The fear of such retaliations keep men hiding in a “tough guise” and acting, even if it isn’t natural to them, as though they are violent, emotionless, homophobic, sexual predators (of women). Even the skinny kid in elementary school would probably rather stand up (and get his poor little butt kicked) to a crowd of his peers than to admit to being a “sissy” or feminine in any way. Even if he ran away from the situation, even his own family (the males) would suck the self-esteem out of him. “Boys don’t cry,” and “Toughen up” is what he’d probably hear. I absolutely agree that this fear exists, because I see boys and men of all ages on a daily basis and I am aware of how they act. I also hear what my brother-in-law tells my 9 year-old nephew whenever he cries over something.
This desperate need to be seen as “manly” feeds many of the biggest problems in society: violence, homophobia, and sexual predation. Society would let men think violence is better than showing emotion. Did I mention that society can really be retarded sometimes (okay, a lot of times)? Statistically, a huge majority of violent crimes are committed by men. Why not just talk out your problems, dude? Oh, right. Emotion is bad, feminine, and gay, even. Obviously, to be gay would definitely go against the social norm of masculinity, so men associate everything bad and anti-masculine with homosexuality, and then use that homophobia to further set in stone that fear of deviating. Unfortunately, because men just can’t get over themselves, homosexuals take the fall for that. Homophobia makes a man more of a man, so discriminating against gay men, just as discriminating against the “sissy” guy, further validates a man’s masculinity. That’s really just disgusting. Men are also expected to display sexual interest with pretty much any girl, but without showing emotion, in order to continue to be manly, thus creating the main reason girls gripe about guys on a daily basis. Not to mention the huge rape problem…
So how do we ameliorate society? For starters, men could get over it. Men should stop living in fear of not fitting a mold, as well as stop discriminating those that don’t fit that mold. In the movie “300,” 300 really tough, violent soldiers, prided on their manliness, fight the good fight against a tyrant in way too much make-up. Now, I thought these guys were sweet in that they were fighting on the right side, but they also fit the mold of society’s manly man. After the captain’s son dies, he says, “I had lived my entire life without regret until now… I never got to tell him that I loved him the most.” He admits that fitting the norm of never showing emotion was his greatest fault. King Leonidas, being the awesome character he is, took this message to heart, and in his dying words (and death in war to a Spartan soldier was a manly honor) cried out to his wife with emotion: “My Queen! My wife! My love…” If a badass Spartan king can show emotion and recognize the fault in the masculine mold, then certainly the modern guys of our society, that typically idolize this movie, can do the same.
It’s not just men, though. Women validate men’s need to be the typical masculine by showing interest in it. There’s the stereotype that women always fall for the bad boy (tough and violent), and that “nice guys finish last,” meaning the emotional and nonviolent ones get shafted by the attractive girls. As attractive as a big, strong man can be, if he’s too brainwashed to realize that violence is stupid, it’s not cute anymore. Personally, I’ve always preferred intelligence and rational thought. More girls should.
And, of course, society’s institutions could stop feeding the nasty cycle. Families, social groups, etc. all encourage boys and men to be masculine, and all discourage them to deviate from that. For men to try to get over their fears and embrace their deviations from that mold would be nearly impossible if society doesn’t stop saying it’s okay to discriminate against those deviants. Even our own government is saying it’s okay to discriminate against homosexuality. Men will continue to live in that fear of ridicule, and that fear will paralyze them from making the necessary change. It’s imperative that society’s institutions stop encouraging and instilling that fear if we will ever get beyond this need to be masculine, violent, and homophobic. Here’s a thought: if the government wants to lower the rates of violent crimes, maybe it should look into its anti-homosexual laws that encourage the discrimination against deviants of traditional gender roles.
Wednesday, February 27, 2008
CRJ-4: I'm not that funny when I run out of Peeps. Please feed me peeps if you want more humor. Thanks.
This week’s readings brought home some frighteningly familiar memories. I doubt I’ll find my humor in this assignment, unfortunately. Instead, it’s a bit more personal this time. I’ll start with the politics of sexuality. I’ve seen for myself the effects of this concept. In many heterosexual relationships, the women see themselves through the lens of their male partner. If the husband isn’t pleased, neither should she be. For the first eighteen years of my life, I saw my mother, who had a full time job as a nurse, also tend to every aspect of the household; often this still wasn’t enough. She cooked every dinner, and if she would try something new and it wasn’t that great, I would just make my dog extremely happy that evening. Then I’d sit there, awkwardly, listening to my father start bickering with her about it. She did all the laundry, dishes, cleaning, you name it; now that I am an adult living on my own, it must have been exhausting with raising the four of us kids. When my dad would get off of work, he’d kick back on the couch and watch TV. Dude, I wish I had time for that when I get home… My house was the epitome of the male dominated patriarch. Anything that challenged it was unacceptable. It really screws with a kid to hear daily yelling…
So as I grew into young adulthood, I carried that baggage. Usually I handled it by never letting any males get close to me emotionally. In a sense for a while there, I was going against the idea that females are the more intimate gender. Emotionally, I was more like a boy, shying away from intimacy because as the author writes, it was “synonymous with weakness.” Not only did I have to overcome some psychological issues from childhood, I had to overcome this gender abnormality. Once in middle school, a girl accused me of being a lesbian. I wasn’t one, but she was calling me out on not being the ideal girl. I got more feminine, appearance-wise, in high school, so that crap ended in middle school. But seriously, I am so sick of the social ideals of heterosexuality, woman should be emotional and intimate, and men should be reserved and dominant. I may not see much inequality in careers or science or whatever, but when it comes to sexuality and the home life, I see it. Too often. You’ve already heard my rant about women and sex, whether they are seen as sluts or prudes.
The last six years before college had really sparked some change in my own microcosm of social normality. My sister catalyzed the first bit of change by having premarital sex, and making it known to my parents by necessity—she was pregnant. Nothing breaks down a parent’s stiff ideals like that. My older brother and I both challenged my father’s strict Catholicism. Religion is another part of that social norm that pisses me off, but that’s another chapter, I suppose. But what really started to break my dad’s seemingly unwavering views on the household was my challenge to the patriarch at a young age. When my mom would get down about an argument, probably over nothing, I’d tell her to pick herself up and not let him get to her like that. Then I’d go to him and challenge his decision to yell at her. If he was going to yell at a woman in the house, I’d rather it have been me than her. As I got older, I no longer tolerated even that. I called him out if he started to. The man ain’t keepin’ me down!!
After I came to college, my parents had time with their empty nest to work on themselves. That, and I could no longer drive them crazy on a daily basis. They worked on their issues, and their incredible stress levels. My dad started compromising. He no longer took a position of dominion in the house. After my freshman year, he even hugged me and told me he loved me. Go figure, a guy showing emotions. Considering we never got along during the entirety of my adolescence, I was really taken aback by his efforts to make a change in himself. Three years later, my dad’s one of my best friends. And this, friends, is the moral to my family-patriarch story. Break the man down, get him to change, haha. No, seriously, it takes a lot of effort to get through to a person raised in a society where the patriarch is expected and idealized. But it’s a necessary fight.
Another part of the reading was on sexuality. After ameliorating my relationship with my dad, I started to take risks in the emotional world. Obviously I was in college at this point, so sexuality played its role. I started being more feminine in the sense that I thought (and still do) that sex should come with love. Typical girl. I wanted that movie-scripted romantic love that society boasts about. Well, when trying to obtain this, don’t try it with a guy hellbent on finding “instrumental” sex (as the author would call it; “sex for its own sake.” Basically, loveless). The author hit it right on the nose when (I assume it’s a she?) she writes that he thinks he “owns or has the right to control her body or sexuality.” If I said I didn’t want to have sex, all hell would break loose. He’d spin it to make me think I was wrong. I guess according to society’s patriarch, I was. Needless to say, I came to my senses and dropped that mother-----er on his butt. J Yay me.
My point is, society is really screwed up when it comes to sexuality and the politics of sexuality. People shouldn’t be scared to be openly gay. People shouldn’t be told they can’t have children if they’re gay. Women shouldn’t feel like they are obliged to be sexual when they don’t feel like it. Women shouldn’t feel like they are less than their husbands. I don’t think I could have shown the truth in these beliefs without not only addressing the readings this week, but addressing my experiences (which coincide with these readings) which have led me to fight society’s screwed up ideas. Things can change if society is challenged when it needs to be. I’ve challenged it, and I’ve seen change, albeit in my small little world. By the way, my current boy is respectful of these ideas, and of me. Not all the guys out there are tainted by the patriarch idea. Thank God for that. I think that shows the slow change occurring.
Oh, and I do nod my head a lot when people talk. I am a girl, according to the book.
Friday, February 22, 2008
Activity 6: I'm a girl, so I should fart kittens and rainbows, right?
Kate Bornstein, from my understanding of it, was born a male and at some point in her life decided to become a female. That’s all peachy with me, but I think she’s on a bit of a mission to disprove genders, even if her arguments don’t always make complete sense. She understands gender as a myriad of characteristics, including religion and ethnicity as well as sexual orientation and personal perception. She believes that femininity and masculinity do not truly exist, but are mere constructions of society to have everyone fit in a mold; that gender exists not as a spectrum of two defined genders, but as something more undefined and infinite in possibility. Personally, I think she takes it a bit far. Religion and ethnicity to me are not gender. Yes, they impact personality, but they are their own categories of how one is defined. Gender is another category in which people can be defined and one which also impacts the personality. I believe this to be a spectrum from the typical masculine to the typical feminine, with everything in between. Notice I did not say male to female. I acknowledge that there can be feminine males and masculine females. I also acknowledge that everyone has a varying degree of masculinity and femininity in them. Male and female are biological, genetic, and yes, exist, much to the annoyance of Bornstein. You can surgically change your sex on the macroscopic level (ie, turn your penis inside out and become a woman), but you still have a Y chromosome, which caused your prenatal gonads to develop into testicles and produce testosterone to make your outward appearance seem “masculine.” You’ll still probably be able to grow more muscle mass than I could… But you know what, that’s fine. I don’t care what you choose to be, but don’t deny that biology plays its role as well. Hormonally, there are chemicals in the body that make us appear masculine and feminine, in whatever varying degree of it. Our personalities as far as gender can vary even more, but I still see it as varying degrees of both of those. It doesn’t deny that everyone is different.
Knowing Bornstein’s perspective, I wasn’t very surprised at the questions asked on her “gender aptitude test.” The questions made about as little sense to me as her papers. I get that since she views gender as a mixture of everything that defines a person (religion, ethnicity, social group, etc. etc. etc. etc…) she would ask questions that include random things such as “goth chicks,” a group commonly viewed down upon. What goth has to do with gender in my definition, I have no idea, so to me it’s weird. But I followed it because in her views, this has something to do with it. However, the answers to the questions bothered me more than the questions themselves. There seemed to be no happy middle, where I fall a lot of times. There tended to be only the two extremes: one side being, there are real men and women and nothing in between!, and the other being, dude, gender doesn’t exist. A lot of the questions dealt with sexual orientation, but the answers to which didn’t give the opportunity for someone who is okay with it and wouldn’t be weirded out by it, but at the same time, doesn’t really swing that way herself. Also, there were questions that were obviously aimed at specific sexes, so answering the questions aimed at men for me had to have screwed up my score, since, well, I guess I answered like a gay guy, because I like guys. If a store clerk called me sir, yeah, I’d be like, WTF?
The results surprised me in that they were quite a bit off. Then again, since the questions were off as well, it doesn’t really surprise me that her test didn’t get me pegged at all. My score was pretty low, and the category in which she placed me was defined as someone with regular gender willies and someone who isn’t always seen as ‘normal,’ by which I suppose she’s referring to the ‘normal’ gender by society’s definition—female and feminine. Actually, I know exactly who I am. I’m never mistaken for masculine, unless we’re playing football and I go balls out on tackling dudes. But even then they say I’m just a tough chick. Not dude-like. I dress too girly and look too girly to be mistaken. And I like guys. In fact, I had a nice dream about Hugh Jackman last night… Yeah, I fit my ‘normal’ gender for the most part, regardless of what this test would think of me. I think it misunderstood my open-mindedness for gender deviance.
I suppose Bornstein is just trying to show people that a social norm can’t really be reached, but I think she just takes it too far. The no gender part really confused me. Being different from the norm doesn’t mean you have no gender… But I guess she was trying to show that people are just different. I think that if maybe she didn’t take things quite as far (and to many, far-fetched) as she did, maybe she would be able to get through to more people. Because we know that people are different, but if you can’t get through to someone who is already open-minded, how do you get your message heard by homophobes?
Only five peeps this time. Easter needs to come and go before I eat so many I explode from peep overload… The sugar high and subsequent crash during writing assignments probably isn’t helping my grade. I need a group discussion thread titled peep-aholics anonymous… I’m halfway serious on that.
Friday, February 15, 2008
CRJ-3: Video Games and Animals... Two of My Favorite Things... and Peeps. Ten of Them.
According to Wajcman, technology has a “male bias,” and “heavily weighted against women” as a result of cultural construction of gender. This link between masculinity and technology, according to the author, stems from technology being “for boys” in games, sciences, and even combat. Our culture has previously associated older technology such as mechanical machinery and weapons as male appropriated because it used to require more physical strength to operate such technology. However, this co-production of masculinity and technology has developed into newer computer-based technologies. Computers are often associated with math and science, which traditionally have been male-dominated subjects. Teachers with a more archaic teaching method who still may believe that boys excel more in science and math compared to girls, encourage boys to learn to use computers more so than the girls. Boys are also more encouraged to play video games whereas girls are encouraged to play with dolls and other such games that foster “caring and social interaction.” Wajcman would believe that this culture has constructed gender roles for men to dominate the technological world, and for women to focus more on the home.
To an extent, I can see some of that cultural construction. My brothers were given video game systems growing up, and I’d always have to wait until they beat the games until they’d let me play. I got the older systems after my brothers got the new ones because I begged and begged to play them. I had very little interest in dolls, and I found it a bit unfair that I couldn’t get the “boy toys.” That was also the 1980s… I was content, however, whenever they would finally let me play with their video games. As I grew older, my parents finally realized that they weren’t going to be able to change my interests in entertainment, so they gave in more and more. I think that also may have something to do with as time progresses forward, people are less likely to embrace such archaic gender roles. Dude, my parents got me a Wii for Christmas in 2006. It’s about time I get the coolest system. My brothers don’t even have one yet. I also remain the Super Smash Brothers (for GameCube) Champion of my friends, and I was the only girl playing.
As far as computers go, I was always encouraged to learn how to use them, both in school and at home. The only time I’ve seen a teacher embrace the “males excel better in math/science and girls excel more in liberal arts” archaic way of thinking was my freshman year of college. My Intro to Psychology professor told us that typically, that’s how it goes. Well, I’ve broken that mold, too, haven’t I? Personally, I think it’s a bunch of crap. Maybe in the past, women were more involved in liberal arts than they were in science because they were encouraged to embrace that gender role. It has nothing to do with intelligence or ability to understand math or science. Now that those gender roles are faltering, more and more women have been entering the science and mathematical worlds.
Wajcman also addresses how women were actually the first computer programmers back in World War Two. Obviously, that was before the feminist movement’s success in getting women into equal jobs. Wajcman writes, “It was because programming was initially viewed as tedious clerical work of low status that it was assigned to women. As the complex skills and value of programming were increasingly recognized, it came to be considered creative, intellectual and demanding 'men's work'. Thus, depending on the circumstances, different cognitive styles may be characterized as 'masculine' or 'feminine' according to the power and status that attaches” (158). Well, I have no doubt that in the 1940s women were given the crap-tastic jobs. We weren’t seen as equals back then. That’s why I am so grateful to the wonderful women of the 1960s. Men were given the more ‘glorious’ jobs, one big one being a soldier in the war. So many, in fact, were soldiers in the war that they had no choice but to allow women to work, otherwise, they wouldn’t have had anyone to do the job. It was a foot in the door for women getting into the workplace, but they had to start at the bottom. So the tedious-seeming computer programming was given to those women. The fact that they could do it shows that there is no biological difference making one sex better than the other with computers and math. Of course, back then, when computers became more important, men had to reclaim these jobs because heaven forbid the women get to keep the ‘important’ jobs. And that’s where the feminists’ second wave comes in… Now that we’re equals, women are re-entering the world of computer programming. My boyfriend’s sister, in fact, has her degree from Tech in Computer Science, and she even recently got promoted at her job. Rock on, ladies.
Switching gears, Roughgarden writes about homosexuality in animals. Dude, I gotta say, I kinda like it. I love animals, and I love how they always show us humans that we are way too judgmental sometimes (okay, a lot of times). Some animals participate in homosexual activity, and none of the other animals think down upon it. I’ve never seen a dog that disliked someone because of his/her sexual orientation, race, gender, etc. Animals see past what a lot of people cannot. People should take a look at themselves through the eyes of an animal, and see how truly prejudiced we are in comparison. Maybe that could help us better ourselves in the process… The article mentions that “over 450 different vertebrate species could be beheaded in Saudi Arabia.” Really now, if 450 species think it’s okay, why do we as 1 species think it’s something worth killing over? This is why I love animals so much… In some ways, they are wiser than humans.
Ah, yes, I’ve gotten carried away with my animal obsession. Back to the assignment! Roughgarden believes that the hetero/homo distinction is a “purely cultural creation.” This belief arose when she witnessed a massive homosexual population that seemed to counter Darwin’s belief that sex is strictly for reproduction. No offense, to Darwin because I totally believe in evolution, and that, yeah, the stronger animals typically were the ones who were able to survive and thus reproduce, but I agree with Roughgarden in the sense that sex also plays a social role, even in non-human species. I’ve known about animal homosexuality long before reading this article, so I’ve had time to come to this understanding on my own. Homosexuality is as natural as having sex to reproduce. One is social bonding, and the other is, well, reproduction. The fact that we have to distinguish homosexuality separate from heterosexuality is because we’re a bass-ackwards species intent on labeling something natural as unnatural. For some reason, we’re the one species that seems to think it’s an aberration. Actually, Roughgarden argues that homosexuality is a feature of “advanced animal communities…the more complex and sophisticated a social system is, the more likely it is to have homosexuality intermixed with heterosexuality.” Considering that the dolphin, a species known to have sex for fun and not just reproduction, has an incredibly advanced brain with more convolutions than even the human brain, I’d say she’s on the right track. The dolphin is incredibly intelligent and sophisticated. Their social system includes recreational sex, much like humans do, and natural homosexual social interactions, again, much like some humans, except some humans resist it.
Wow. This is longer than usual, even for me. This is probably due to the fact that in the time it took me to write this, I ate 10 peeps, which consist of sugar-coated sugar. I succeeded in my goal of gaining a burst of energy after a long and draining week, but it may have been overkill…