Friday, February 29, 2008

Activity 7: Why I'm Glad I Don't Have a Penis

            Ah, so men are the root of all of society’s problems.  Ha, I’m kidding (kind of), but perhaps masculinity in the way that society has constructed it is.  Men keep each other in constant awareness of their masculinity.  Anything that goes against the gender norms of “manliness” is immediately attacked, and usually by other men, because for some reason they need the approval of each other.  These norms include violence, not showing emotion (being “tough”), and even walking a certain way, dressing a certain way, and treating women a certain way.  That last one may explain some of the douchebagery of young adult men and their obsession with loveless sex.  Any deviance form these norms leave a man open to ridicule, name-calling (sissy, the f-word that I don’t use [and it doesn’t rhyme with duck, because I use that one], etc), and even violence.  The fear of such retaliations keep men hiding in a “tough guise” and acting, even if it isn’t natural to them, as though they are violent, emotionless, homophobic, sexual predators (of women).  Even the skinny kid in elementary school would probably rather stand up (and get his poor little butt kicked) to a crowd of his peers than to admit to being a “sissy” or feminine in any way.  Even if he ran away from the situation, even his own family (the males) would suck the self-esteem out of him.  “Boys don’t cry,” and “Toughen up” is what he’d probably hear.  I absolutely agree that this fear exists, because I see boys and men of all ages on a daily basis and I am aware of how they act.  I also hear what my brother-in-law tells my 9 year-old nephew whenever he cries over something.

            This desperate need to be seen as “manly” feeds many of the biggest problems in society: violence, homophobia, and sexual predation.  Society would let men think violence is better than showing emotion.  Did I mention that society can really be retarded sometimes (okay, a lot of times)?  Statistically, a huge majority of violent crimes are committed by men.  Why not just talk out your problems, dude?  Oh, right.  Emotion is bad, feminine, and gay, even.  Obviously, to be gay would definitely go against the social norm of masculinity, so men associate everything bad and anti-masculine with homosexuality, and then use that homophobia to further set in stone that fear of deviating.  Unfortunately, because men just can’t get over themselves, homosexuals take the fall for that.  Homophobia makes a man more of a man, so discriminating against gay men, just as discriminating against the “sissy” guy, further validates a man’s masculinity.  That’s really just disgusting.  Men are also expected to display sexual interest with pretty much any girl, but without showing emotion, in order to continue to be manly, thus creating the main reason girls gripe about guys on a daily basis.  Not to mention the huge rape problem…

            So how do we ameliorate society?  For starters, men could get over it.  Men should stop living in fear of not fitting a mold, as well as stop discriminating those that don’t fit that mold.  In the movie “300,” 300 really tough, violent soldiers, prided on their manliness, fight the good fight against a tyrant in way too much make-up.  Now, I thought these guys were sweet in that they were fighting on the right side, but they also fit the mold of society’s manly man.  After the captain’s son dies, he says, “I had lived my entire life without regret until now… I never got to tell him that I loved him the most.”  He admits that fitting the norm of never showing emotion was his greatest fault.  King Leonidas, being the awesome character he is, took this message to heart, and in his dying words (and death in war to a Spartan soldier was a manly honor) cried out to his wife with emotion: “My Queen! My wife! My love…”  If a badass Spartan king can show emotion and recognize the fault in the masculine mold, then certainly the modern guys of our society, that typically idolize this movie, can do the same.

It’s not just men, though.  Women validate men’s need to be the typical masculine by showing interest in it.  There’s the stereotype that women always fall for the bad boy (tough and violent), and that “nice guys finish last,” meaning the emotional and nonviolent ones get shafted by the attractive girls.  As attractive as a big, strong man can be, if he’s too brainwashed to realize that violence is stupid, it’s not cute anymore.  Personally, I’ve always preferred intelligence and rational thought.  More girls should.

And, of course, society’s institutions could stop feeding the nasty cycle.  Families, social groups, etc. all encourage boys and men to be masculine, and all discourage them to deviate from that.  For men to try to get over their fears and embrace their deviations from that mold would be nearly impossible if society doesn’t stop saying it’s okay to discriminate against those deviants.  Even our own government is saying it’s okay to discriminate against homosexuality.  Men will continue to live in that fear of ridicule, and that fear will paralyze them from making the necessary change.  It’s imperative that society’s institutions stop encouraging and instilling that fear if we will ever get beyond this need to be masculine, violent, and homophobic.  Here’s a thought: if the government wants to lower the rates of violent crimes, maybe it should look into its anti-homosexual laws that encourage the discrimination against deviants of traditional gender roles.

1 comment:

Donna said...

excellent commentary - very well done -- great how you bring in specific media examples (I have to see 300 now)...

I do want to point out something you said in the last section about anti homosexual laws that deal with gender deviants -- are homosexuals gender deviants? can you be perfectly/normatively gendered and a homosexual?