Friday, February 8, 2008

The Adventures of Supersperm

            Martin claims that science textbooks shed a darkness over female reproduction, calling menstruation a failure, and shed a huge light over male reproduction, emphasizing the astronomical feat of sperm production.  Well, in my own experience (and I’ve read a lot of textbooks on this), the books never have this connotation.  If anything, the books refer to the egg as the holy grail, and the millions of sperm a day an astronomical failure and the most inefficient system ever.  Eggs that are not inseminated are indeed failures, because their purpose was to produce a zygote and they didn’t.  It’s not knocking women down, it’s just calling it as it is—one failure per month.  Books also acknowledge that the millions of sperm that don’t make it to the egg are failures, because they also did not produce the zygote.  That’s millions of failures per day. That hardly makes men look superior.  Because sperm tend to be so inefficient, they really do have to have that “whiplashlike motion and strong lurches,” because if they don’t, they don’t get the holy grail.  The egg really doesn’t move that fast.  Sorry, but if that’s sexist, then blame God for making the egg big and slow.  Honestly, I kind of like how we don’t have to do any of the work.  And I’d REALLY hate having to menstruate a few million times a day.

            Martin states that this “stereotypical” view on reproduction leads to a social outlook on “passive” females and “heroic” males.  Based on her beliefs, this female inferiority and male superiority in science influences society to view the sexes as just that.  I don’t see it.  I mean, I’m sorry that the egg doesn’t dart off into the male wilderness in search of sperm, but that’s just how it is.  It doesn’t mean that females are passive or that males are heroic.  No one I have ever met sees science like that (a LOT of females included in that!).  Males, if anything, are seen more so as inefficient.  Even my boy admits that his own precious reproductive system (meaning the male’s) is one of the most ineffective he’s heard of.  For what it’s worth, the boy is a graduate student working towards a Ph.D. in biochemistry.  There’s a scientist for you, admitting the female reproductive system is more efficient.

            I have to admit, I found the Star Wars take on the egg/sperm interactions quite hilarious.  I love Star Wars, though.  I couldn’t catch any gender connotations, though.  The ships, or sperm, were driven my males, but that just represented that the sperm were from the male reproductive system.  It’s true that the sperm are much faster, and their goal is to reach the egg, just like the fighters were faster than the Death Star, and their goal was to get their little white friends (blasts) inside.  George Lucas cannot be held accountable for the fact that they blew up the Death Star, because it was not his intention to represent gametes.  Unless the guy who merged the two videos thought that sperm blow up the egg, which would mean the guy has NOT been paying attention to science, which would thus exonerate science as the reason for any interpretation of female inferiority, he probably just thought it was funny that sperm dart around the egg like fighter jets around the Death Star, and that the phrase, “that’s one in a million!” relates to the fact that only one in a few million sperm are successful.  Actually, that makes me think it’s making fun of the males now.

I honestly cannot see any female inferiority or male superiority in either the clip or my pretty science books.  And maybe people just interpret things differently; take the constitution for example—old dudes have been arguing over that thing since it’s conception.  So maybe Martin is one party and I’m another, and for the life of us, we can’t understand each other’s views.  To each her own.

PS (and this really has little to do with the assignment): "Supersperm" is a term I created to describe myself as a sperm.  My mother had gotten her fallopian tubes tied nearly three years before I joined the world.  SURPRISE!!!  My brothers used this to make me think Mom didn't want me (kinda like making the little sister believe she was adopted).  Older brothers are way more oppressive than science.

1 comment:

Donna said...

you are one hysterical supersperm - and I love your last sentence... and found your response entertaining... that being said, you seem to have missed Martin's main point...

Martin is using the stories of conception in textbooks as an example of how social meanings are written into science -- how we see the world, even how we see science (which is supposedly objective right?) is shaped by social meanings - including those about gender -- this is a story about how science is socially constructed...

here are some notes on Martin's main points:
- Scientific knowledge, believed to be factual and objective, reflects biases against women that are shared by the societies in which this knowledge is produced (10)

- Martin shows how our ideas about gender (social ideas) are part of the framework through which we understand and communicate science. Think about it. It makes sense that we use common metaphors (like the fairy tale rescuing of the princess) to teach something. Metaphors help us learn. However, as Martin notes these metaphors are not harmless – there are side effects.

- The models that biologists use to describe their data can have important social effects…
---> Import cultural ideas about active males and passive females into gametes (implanting social imagery on representations of nature)
---> Then reimport exactly the same imagery as a natural explanation of social phenomenon

-- In the least the imagery keeps alive stereotypes…that these stereotypes are at the level of the cell – a powerful move to make them seem so natural as to be beyond alteration… This process naturalizes our stereotypes about gender. Next time someone questions whether women are supposed to be passive and men active and if this is a social construct or biological reality… the example of the egg and the sperm – because we imported sexist language-- says that gender difference is natural!!! Ouch! A significant side effect…