Friday, February 1, 2008

CRJ-1. Privilege and Power

            For people to admit they are over-privileged may mean admitting they should relinquish some of their powers and privileges.  On the other hand, referring to others as disadvantaged places the fault not in the hands of those who are privileged, but of those who have failed to gain such privileges.  It does not suggest that the privileged should give up any power; it suggests that the disadvantaged should work harder to be on par with the privileged.

            Or maybe the advantaged just can’t see their own privileges because they were taught that their privileges were simply the norm.  Through school, the media, or any other part of society, privileges are given invisibly (hence, “invisible package”) because they are standardized.  Anything less than privileged is abnormal, and thus can be judged as not good enough or not working hard enough.  You know how society likes to pick on “abnormalities.”

            I could walk into 7-11 at 2am and the cashier would not flinch.  I’m a thin, blonde, white girl—completely harmless.  Lucky for the cashier, I’m more of a pacifist anyway, but how could he know that?  How could he know that I wasn’t packing a hidden weapon waiting for an opportunity to score some extra cash?  Just because of my appearance?  My skin color?  My gender?  If, then, a male of middle-eastern heritage, or a big linebacker-esque black guy walked in right after me, would the cashier feel a sudden chill of fear?  In almost every TV show I’ve seen in which a late-night cashier get robbed at gun-point, it’s been a minority holding the trigger.

            I constantly see the fact that I was born into privilege, but I don’t necessarily link it to my race or gender (other than the fact I could grab a beer at midnight with no weird looks from the cashier).  What I recognize is my socioeconomic class.  I have been taught that the norm is to obtain a college education, and those who do not didn’t have their priorities straight, didn’t work hard enough, or just weren’t smart enough to do it.  They are “disadvantaged.”  But I see as a young adult that the reason I’m getting my degree in May is because my parents have been able to afford to send me here at Virginia Tech for four years, and for another four years in Vet School.  People of the same intelligence as me may be labeled as less because they couldn’t afford to go to college.

            The bootstrap myth alleges that anyone can find economic success; all they need is hard work and ambition.  Well, I won’t negate the importance of hard work, but one usually needs to that initial platform of privilege to assert such hard work; otherwise, they could be working hard scrubbing toilets (I am NOT putting that job down, by the way. Anyone who has lived in a dorm should have a very good appreciation of what they do for us!) earning minimum wage.  Economically speaking, they weren’t successful, and according to the bootstrap myth, it’s either because they didn’t work hard enough or just generally weren’t good enough.  Whatever helps the Wall Street guys sleep better at night.  Maybe they could not afford a college education, and had to make a living somehow.  Where would I be if my parents couldn’t have paid for my education?  I’ve worked my butt off these past four years but if I never had the opportunity to be in college, that hard work wouldn’t have gotten me nearly as far as it has.  I had an opportunity to apply my ambition because I was privileged enough to have one.

            As a female, I have only felt less privileged in two things: they won’t let me play tackle football (even though my older brother taught me how to tackle), and some guys have pursued me only as a sex-object and not a person… and then I’m the “prude” for not putting out.  But then if I had, then I’d be the “slut.”  Great win/win situation there, huh?  Now if a guy is put in the same situation, he’s either a “pimp” for getting the girl in bed or he’s a great catch if he decides to get to know her first.  Whatever, I’ll take the “prude” card over to my “great catch” and get over it.  I still want to play football, and not that fairy-princess flag version, either.

            Switching gears to the part I’ve been avoiding because I’m too sick to be angry.  Homophobia and sexism join forces to become one of the more annoyingly ignorant and intolerant ideals currently infiltrating society’s institutions.  It bases itself on patriarchal power and the “nuclear family” (Dad, Mom, two-and-a-half children and a Labrador Retriever... okay, I added the dog to that, but seriously, it’s not family without the canine addition).  This nuclear family, usually with Dad as the head-of-house, makes the heterosexual man absolutely necessary to society.  This being said, he needs his heterosexual wife to bear his children.  This is the norm that has been ingrained in our minds.  Anything that challenges this norm challenges society itself, and then all Hell breaks loose.  Homosexual men threaten that patriarch figure of the nuclear family.  Men don’t like to give up that power, so homosexual men become victims of ignorant, power-hungry idealists.  Homosexual women, of course, also threaten that nuclear family and patriarchal power because if women have families with women, where do the men go?  Men no longer needed?  Men no longer in power?  Panic!  So lesbians, too, are victimized.

            According to Suzanne Pharr, being labeled a lesbian threatens all women, regardless of sexual orientation.  Homosexual women are no different from heterosexual women on the outside.  Women of both orientations vary in appearance, dating habits (long-term, short-term, etc), and there’s no real way of definitively proving her sexuality.  So anyone can point the finger at any woman to make her an outcast.  If a student dislikes a teacher, he can point his ignorant little finger and have her fired.  This fear of being victimized and ostracized for threatening the norm that society teaches us leads to compulsive heterosexuality, that is, people would rather try being heterosexual, even if they are not, to avoid the backlash.  They step back into the line society drew for them. To make matters worse, those who don’t understand feminism—those who think feminists are just a bunch of man-hating lesbians—associate feminism with lesbianism, so the feminists get the same nasty treatment from them.  Awesome step backwards, society.

I’m starting to see the inequality between the sexes now… a little.

1 comment:

Donna said...

excellent...

my favorite line of course: "awesome step backwards, society"