Friday, February 29, 2008

Activity 7: Why I'm Glad I Don't Have a Penis

            Ah, so men are the root of all of society’s problems.  Ha, I’m kidding (kind of), but perhaps masculinity in the way that society has constructed it is.  Men keep each other in constant awareness of their masculinity.  Anything that goes against the gender norms of “manliness” is immediately attacked, and usually by other men, because for some reason they need the approval of each other.  These norms include violence, not showing emotion (being “tough”), and even walking a certain way, dressing a certain way, and treating women a certain way.  That last one may explain some of the douchebagery of young adult men and their obsession with loveless sex.  Any deviance form these norms leave a man open to ridicule, name-calling (sissy, the f-word that I don’t use [and it doesn’t rhyme with duck, because I use that one], etc), and even violence.  The fear of such retaliations keep men hiding in a “tough guise” and acting, even if it isn’t natural to them, as though they are violent, emotionless, homophobic, sexual predators (of women).  Even the skinny kid in elementary school would probably rather stand up (and get his poor little butt kicked) to a crowd of his peers than to admit to being a “sissy” or feminine in any way.  Even if he ran away from the situation, even his own family (the males) would suck the self-esteem out of him.  “Boys don’t cry,” and “Toughen up” is what he’d probably hear.  I absolutely agree that this fear exists, because I see boys and men of all ages on a daily basis and I am aware of how they act.  I also hear what my brother-in-law tells my 9 year-old nephew whenever he cries over something.

            This desperate need to be seen as “manly” feeds many of the biggest problems in society: violence, homophobia, and sexual predation.  Society would let men think violence is better than showing emotion.  Did I mention that society can really be retarded sometimes (okay, a lot of times)?  Statistically, a huge majority of violent crimes are committed by men.  Why not just talk out your problems, dude?  Oh, right.  Emotion is bad, feminine, and gay, even.  Obviously, to be gay would definitely go against the social norm of masculinity, so men associate everything bad and anti-masculine with homosexuality, and then use that homophobia to further set in stone that fear of deviating.  Unfortunately, because men just can’t get over themselves, homosexuals take the fall for that.  Homophobia makes a man more of a man, so discriminating against gay men, just as discriminating against the “sissy” guy, further validates a man’s masculinity.  That’s really just disgusting.  Men are also expected to display sexual interest with pretty much any girl, but without showing emotion, in order to continue to be manly, thus creating the main reason girls gripe about guys on a daily basis.  Not to mention the huge rape problem…

            So how do we ameliorate society?  For starters, men could get over it.  Men should stop living in fear of not fitting a mold, as well as stop discriminating those that don’t fit that mold.  In the movie “300,” 300 really tough, violent soldiers, prided on their manliness, fight the good fight against a tyrant in way too much make-up.  Now, I thought these guys were sweet in that they were fighting on the right side, but they also fit the mold of society’s manly man.  After the captain’s son dies, he says, “I had lived my entire life without regret until now… I never got to tell him that I loved him the most.”  He admits that fitting the norm of never showing emotion was his greatest fault.  King Leonidas, being the awesome character he is, took this message to heart, and in his dying words (and death in war to a Spartan soldier was a manly honor) cried out to his wife with emotion: “My Queen! My wife! My love…”  If a badass Spartan king can show emotion and recognize the fault in the masculine mold, then certainly the modern guys of our society, that typically idolize this movie, can do the same.

It’s not just men, though.  Women validate men’s need to be the typical masculine by showing interest in it.  There’s the stereotype that women always fall for the bad boy (tough and violent), and that “nice guys finish last,” meaning the emotional and nonviolent ones get shafted by the attractive girls.  As attractive as a big, strong man can be, if he’s too brainwashed to realize that violence is stupid, it’s not cute anymore.  Personally, I’ve always preferred intelligence and rational thought.  More girls should.

And, of course, society’s institutions could stop feeding the nasty cycle.  Families, social groups, etc. all encourage boys and men to be masculine, and all discourage them to deviate from that.  For men to try to get over their fears and embrace their deviations from that mold would be nearly impossible if society doesn’t stop saying it’s okay to discriminate against those deviants.  Even our own government is saying it’s okay to discriminate against homosexuality.  Men will continue to live in that fear of ridicule, and that fear will paralyze them from making the necessary change.  It’s imperative that society’s institutions stop encouraging and instilling that fear if we will ever get beyond this need to be masculine, violent, and homophobic.  Here’s a thought: if the government wants to lower the rates of violent crimes, maybe it should look into its anti-homosexual laws that encourage the discrimination against deviants of traditional gender roles.

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

CRJ-4: I'm not that funny when I run out of Peeps. Please feed me peeps if you want more humor. Thanks.

This week’s readings brought home some frighteningly familiar memories.  I doubt I’ll find my humor in this assignment, unfortunately.  Instead, it’s a bit more personal this time.  I’ll start with the politics of sexuality.  I’ve seen for myself the effects of this concept.  In many heterosexual relationships, the women see themselves through the lens of their male partner.  If the husband isn’t pleased, neither should she be.  For the first eighteen years of my life, I saw my mother, who had a full time job as a nurse, also tend to every aspect of the household; often this still wasn’t enough.  She cooked every dinner, and if she would try something new and it wasn’t that great, I would just make my dog extremely happy that evening.  Then I’d sit there, awkwardly, listening to my father start bickering with her about it.  She did all the laundry, dishes, cleaning, you name it; now that I am an adult living on my own, it must have been exhausting with raising the four of us kids.  When my dad would get off of work, he’d kick back on the couch and watch TV.  Dude, I wish I had time for that when I get home… My house was the epitome of the male dominated patriarch.  Anything that challenged it was unacceptable.  It really screws with a kid to hear daily yelling…

            So as I grew into young adulthood, I carried that baggage.  Usually I handled it by never letting any males get close to me emotionally.  In a sense for a while there, I was going against the idea that females are the more intimate gender.  Emotionally, I was more like a boy, shying away from intimacy because as the author writes, it was “synonymous with weakness.”  Not only did I have to overcome some psychological issues from childhood, I had to overcome this gender abnormality.  Once in middle school, a girl accused me of being a lesbian.  I wasn’t one, but she was calling me out on not being the ideal girl.  I got more feminine, appearance-wise, in high school, so that crap ended in middle school.  But seriously, I am so sick of the social ideals of heterosexuality, woman should be emotional and intimate, and men should be reserved and dominant.  I may not see much inequality in careers or science or whatever, but when it comes to sexuality and the home life, I see it.  Too often.  You’ve already heard my rant about women and sex, whether they are seen as sluts or prudes.

            The last six years before college had really sparked some change in my own microcosm of social normality.  My sister catalyzed the first bit of change by having premarital sex, and making it known to my parents by necessity—she was pregnant.  Nothing breaks down a parent’s stiff ideals like that.  My older brother and I both challenged my father’s strict Catholicism.  Religion is another part of that social norm that pisses me off, but that’s another chapter, I suppose.  But what really started to break my dad’s seemingly unwavering views on the household was my challenge to the patriarch at a young age.  When my mom would get down about an argument, probably over nothing, I’d tell her to pick herself up and not let him get to her like that.  Then I’d go to him and challenge his decision to yell at her.  If he was going to yell at a woman in the house, I’d rather it have been me than her.  As I got older, I no longer tolerated even that.  I called him out if he started to.  The man ain’t keepin’ me down!!

After I came to college, my parents had time with their empty nest to work on themselves.  That, and I could no longer drive them crazy on a daily basis.  They worked on their issues, and their incredible stress levels.  My dad started compromising.  He no longer took a position of dominion in the house.  After my freshman year, he even hugged me and told me he loved me.  Go figure, a guy showing emotions.  Considering we never got along during the entirety of my adolescence, I was really taken aback by his efforts to make a change in himself.  Three years later, my dad’s one of my best friends.  And this, friends, is the moral to my family-patriarch story.  Break the man down, get him to change, haha.  No, seriously, it takes a lot of effort to get through to a person raised in a society where the patriarch is expected and idealized.  But it’s a necessary fight.

Another part of the reading was on sexuality.  After ameliorating my relationship with my dad, I started to take risks in the emotional world.  Obviously I was in college at this point, so sexuality played its role.  I started being more feminine in the sense that I thought (and still do) that sex should come with love.  Typical girl.  I wanted that movie-scripted romantic love that society boasts about.  Well, when trying to obtain this, don’t try it with a guy hellbent on finding “instrumental” sex (as the author would call it; “sex for its own sake.”  Basically, loveless).  The author hit it right on the nose when (I assume it’s a she?) she writes that he thinks he “owns or has the right to control her body or sexuality.”  If I said I didn’t want to have sex, all hell would break loose.  He’d spin it to make me think I was wrong.  I guess according to society’s patriarch, I was.  Needless to say, I came to my senses and dropped that mother-----er on his butt.  J Yay me.

My point is, society is really screwed up when it comes to sexuality and the politics of sexuality.  People shouldn’t be scared to be openly gay.  People shouldn’t be told they can’t have children if they’re gay.  Women shouldn’t feel like they are obliged to be sexual when they don’t feel like it.  Women shouldn’t feel like they are less than their husbands.  I don’t think I could have shown the truth in these beliefs without not only addressing the readings this week, but addressing my experiences (which coincide with these readings) which have led me to fight society’s screwed up ideas. Things can change if society is challenged when it needs to be.  I’ve challenged it, and I’ve seen change, albeit in my small little world.  By the way, my current boy is respectful of these ideas, and of me.  Not all the guys out there are tainted by the patriarch idea.  Thank God for that.  I think that shows the slow change occurring.

Oh, and I do nod my head a lot when people talk.  I am a girl, according to the book.

Friday, February 22, 2008

Activity 6: I'm a girl, so I should fart kittens and rainbows, right?

            Kate Bornstein, from my understanding of it, was born a male and at some point in her life decided to become a female.  That’s all peachy with me, but I think she’s on a bit of a mission to disprove genders, even if her arguments don’t always make complete sense.  She understands gender as a myriad of characteristics, including religion and ethnicity as well as sexual orientation and personal perception.  She believes that femininity and masculinity do not truly exist, but are mere constructions of society to have everyone fit in a mold; that gender exists not as a spectrum of two defined genders, but as something more undefined and infinite in possibility.  Personally, I think she takes it a bit far.  Religion and ethnicity to me are not gender.  Yes, they impact personality, but they are their own categories of how one is defined.  Gender is another category in which people can be defined and one which also impacts the personality.  I believe this to be a spectrum from the typical masculine to the typical feminine, with everything in between.  Notice I did not say male to female.  I acknowledge that there can be feminine males and masculine females.  I also acknowledge that everyone has a varying degree of masculinity and femininity in them.  Male and female are biological, genetic, and yes, exist, much to the annoyance of Bornstein.  You can surgically change your sex on the macroscopic level (ie, turn your penis inside out and become a woman), but you still have a Y chromosome, which caused your prenatal gonads to develop into testicles and produce testosterone to make your outward appearance seem “masculine.”  You’ll still probably be able to grow more muscle mass than I could… But you know what, that’s fine.  I don’t care what you choose to be, but don’t deny that biology plays its role as well.  Hormonally, there are chemicals in the body that make us appear masculine and feminine, in whatever varying degree of it.  Our personalities as far as gender can vary even more, but I still see it as varying degrees of both of those.  It doesn’t deny that everyone is different.

            Knowing Bornstein’s perspective, I wasn’t very surprised at the questions asked on her “gender aptitude test.”  The questions made about as little sense to me as her papers.  I get that since she views gender as a mixture of everything that defines a person (religion, ethnicity, social group, etc. etc. etc. etc…) she would ask questions that include random things such as “goth chicks,” a group commonly viewed down upon.  What goth has to do with gender in my definition, I have no idea, so to me it’s weird.  But I followed it because in her views, this has something to do with it.  However, the answers to the questions bothered me more than the questions themselves.  There seemed to be no happy middle, where I fall a lot of times.  There tended to be only the two extremes: one side being, there are real men and women and nothing in between!, and the other being, dude, gender doesn’t exist.  A lot of the questions dealt with sexual orientation, but the answers to which didn’t give the opportunity for someone who is okay with it and wouldn’t be weirded out by it, but at the same time, doesn’t really swing that way herself.  Also, there were questions that were obviously aimed at specific sexes, so answering the questions aimed at men for me had to have screwed up my score, since, well, I guess I answered like a gay guy, because I like guys.  If a store clerk called me sir, yeah, I’d be like, WTF?

            The results surprised me in that they were quite a bit off.  Then again, since the questions were off as well, it doesn’t really surprise me that her test didn’t get me pegged at all.  My score was pretty low, and the category in which she placed me was defined as someone with regular gender willies and someone who isn’t always seen as ‘normal,’ by which I suppose she’s referring to the ‘normal’ gender by society’s definition—female and feminine.  Actually, I know exactly who I am.  I’m never mistaken for masculine, unless we’re playing football and I go balls out on tackling dudes.  But even then they say I’m just a tough chick.  Not dude-like.  I dress too girly and look too girly to be mistaken.  And I like guys.  In fact, I had a nice dream about Hugh Jackman last night… Yeah, I fit my ‘normal’ gender for the most part, regardless of what this test would think of me.  I think it misunderstood my open-mindedness for gender deviance.

            I suppose Bornstein is just trying to show people that a social norm can’t really be reached, but I think she just takes it too far.  The no gender part really confused me.  Being different from the norm doesn’t mean you have no gender… But I guess she was trying to show that people are just different.  I think that if maybe she didn’t take things quite as far (and to many, far-fetched) as she did, maybe she would be able to get through to more people.  Because we know that people are different, but if you can’t get through to someone who is already open-minded, how do you get your message heard by homophobes?

            Only five peeps this time.  Easter needs to come and go before I eat so many I explode from peep overload… The sugar high and subsequent crash during writing assignments probably isn’t helping my grade.  I need a group discussion thread titled peep-aholics anonymous… I’m halfway serious on that.

Friday, February 15, 2008

CRJ-3: Video Games and Animals... Two of My Favorite Things... and Peeps. Ten of Them.

According to Wajcman, technology has a “male bias,” and “heavily weighted against women” as a result of cultural construction of gender.  This link between masculinity and technology, according to the author, stems from technology being “for boys” in games, sciences, and even combat.  Our culture has previously associated older technology such as mechanical machinery and weapons as male appropriated because it used to require more physical strength to operate such technology.  However, this co-production of masculinity and technology has developed into newer computer-based technologies.  Computers are often associated with math and science, which traditionally have been male-dominated subjects.  Teachers with a more archaic teaching method who still may believe that boys excel more in science and math compared to girls, encourage boys to learn to use computers more so than the girls.  Boys are also more encouraged to play video games whereas girls are encouraged to play with dolls and other such games that foster “caring and social interaction.”  Wajcman would believe that this culture has constructed gender roles for men to dominate the technological world, and for women to focus more on the home.

            To an extent, I can see some of that cultural construction.  My brothers were given video game systems growing up, and I’d always have to wait until they beat the games until they’d let me play.  I got the older systems after my brothers got the new ones because I begged and begged to play them.  I had very little interest in dolls, and I found it a bit unfair that I couldn’t get the “boy toys.”  That was also the 1980s… I was content, however, whenever they would finally let me play with their video games.  As I grew older, my parents finally realized that they weren’t going to be able to change my interests in entertainment, so they gave in more and more.  I think that also may have something to do with as time progresses forward, people are less likely to embrace such archaic gender roles.  Dude, my parents got me a Wii for Christmas in 2006.   It’s about time I get the coolest system.  My brothers don’t even have one yet.  I also remain the Super Smash Brothers (for GameCube) Champion of my friends, and I was the only girl playing. 

As far as computers go, I was always encouraged to learn how to use them, both in school and at home.  The only time I’ve seen a teacher embrace the “males excel better in math/science and girls excel more in liberal arts” archaic way of thinking was my freshman year of college.  My Intro to Psychology professor told us that typically, that’s how it goes.  Well, I’ve broken that mold, too, haven’t I?  Personally, I think it’s a bunch of crap.  Maybe in the past, women were more involved in liberal arts than they were in science because they were encouraged to embrace that gender role.  It has nothing to do with intelligence or ability to understand math or science.  Now that those gender roles are faltering, more and more women have been entering the science and mathematical worlds. 

Wajcman also addresses how women were actually the first computer programmers back in World War Two.  Obviously, that was before the feminist movement’s success in getting women into equal jobs.  Wajcman writes, “It was because programming was initially viewed as tedious clerical work of low status that it was assigned to women. As the complex skills and value of programming were increasingly recognized, it came to be considered creative, intellectual and demanding 'men's work'. Thus, depending on the circumstances, different cognitive styles may be characterized as 'masculine' or 'feminine' according to the power and status that attaches” (158).  Well, I have no doubt that in the 1940s women were given the crap-tastic jobs.  We weren’t seen as equals back then.  That’s why I am so grateful to the wonderful women of the 1960s.  Men were given the more ‘glorious’ jobs, one big one being a soldier in the war.  So many, in fact, were soldiers in the war that they had no choice but to allow women to work, otherwise, they wouldn’t have had anyone to do the job.  It was a foot in the door for women getting into the workplace, but they had to start at the bottom.  So the tedious-seeming computer programming was given to those women.  The fact that they could do it shows that there is no biological difference making one sex better than the other with computers and math.  Of course, back then, when computers became more important, men had to reclaim these jobs because heaven forbid the women get to keep the ‘important’ jobs.  And that’s where the feminists’ second wave comes in…  Now that we’re equals, women are re-entering the world of computer programming.  My boyfriend’s sister, in fact, has her degree from Tech in Computer Science, and she even recently got promoted at her job.  Rock on, ladies.

            Switching gears, Roughgarden writes about homosexuality in animals.  Dude, I gotta say, I kinda like it.  I love animals, and I love how they always show us humans that we are way too judgmental sometimes (okay, a lot of times).  Some animals participate in homosexual activity, and none of the other animals think down upon it.  I’ve never seen a dog that disliked someone because of his/her sexual orientation, race, gender, etc.  Animals see past what a lot of people cannot.  People should take a look at themselves through the eyes of an animal, and see how truly prejudiced we are in comparison.  Maybe that could help us better ourselves in the process… The article mentions that “over 450 different vertebrate species could be beheaded in Saudi Arabia.”  Really now, if 450 species think it’s okay, why do we as 1 species think it’s something worth killing over?  This is why I love animals so much…  In some ways, they are wiser than humans.

            Ah, yes, I’ve gotten carried away with my animal obsession.  Back to the assignment!  Roughgarden believes that the hetero/homo distinction is a “purely cultural creation.”  This belief arose when she witnessed a massive homosexual population that seemed to counter Darwin’s belief that sex is strictly for reproduction.  No offense, to Darwin because I totally believe in evolution, and that, yeah, the stronger animals typically were the ones who were able to survive and thus reproduce, but I agree with Roughgarden in the sense that sex also plays a social role, even in non-human species.  I’ve known about animal homosexuality long before reading this article, so I’ve had time to come to this understanding on my own.  Homosexuality is as natural as having sex to reproduce.  One is social bonding, and the other is, well, reproduction.  The fact that we have to distinguish homosexuality separate from heterosexuality is because we’re a bass-ackwards species intent on labeling something natural as unnatural.  For some reason, we’re the one species that seems to think it’s an aberration.  Actually, Roughgarden argues that homosexuality is a feature of “advanced animal communities…the more complex and sophisticated a social system is, the more likely it is to have homosexuality intermixed with heterosexuality.”  Considering that the dolphin, a species known to have sex for fun and not just reproduction, has an incredibly advanced brain with more convolutions than even the human brain, I’d say she’s on the right track.  The dolphin is incredibly intelligent and sophisticated.  Their social system includes recreational sex, much like humans do, and natural homosexual social interactions, again, much like some humans, except some humans resist it.

            Wow. This is longer than usual, even for me.  This is probably due to the fact that in the time it took me to write this, I ate 10 peeps, which consist of sugar-coated sugar.  I succeeded in my goal of gaining a burst of energy after a long and draining week, but it may have been overkill…

Friday, February 8, 2008

The Adventures of Supersperm

            Martin claims that science textbooks shed a darkness over female reproduction, calling menstruation a failure, and shed a huge light over male reproduction, emphasizing the astronomical feat of sperm production.  Well, in my own experience (and I’ve read a lot of textbooks on this), the books never have this connotation.  If anything, the books refer to the egg as the holy grail, and the millions of sperm a day an astronomical failure and the most inefficient system ever.  Eggs that are not inseminated are indeed failures, because their purpose was to produce a zygote and they didn’t.  It’s not knocking women down, it’s just calling it as it is—one failure per month.  Books also acknowledge that the millions of sperm that don’t make it to the egg are failures, because they also did not produce the zygote.  That’s millions of failures per day. That hardly makes men look superior.  Because sperm tend to be so inefficient, they really do have to have that “whiplashlike motion and strong lurches,” because if they don’t, they don’t get the holy grail.  The egg really doesn’t move that fast.  Sorry, but if that’s sexist, then blame God for making the egg big and slow.  Honestly, I kind of like how we don’t have to do any of the work.  And I’d REALLY hate having to menstruate a few million times a day.

            Martin states that this “stereotypical” view on reproduction leads to a social outlook on “passive” females and “heroic” males.  Based on her beliefs, this female inferiority and male superiority in science influences society to view the sexes as just that.  I don’t see it.  I mean, I’m sorry that the egg doesn’t dart off into the male wilderness in search of sperm, but that’s just how it is.  It doesn’t mean that females are passive or that males are heroic.  No one I have ever met sees science like that (a LOT of females included in that!).  Males, if anything, are seen more so as inefficient.  Even my boy admits that his own precious reproductive system (meaning the male’s) is one of the most ineffective he’s heard of.  For what it’s worth, the boy is a graduate student working towards a Ph.D. in biochemistry.  There’s a scientist for you, admitting the female reproductive system is more efficient.

            I have to admit, I found the Star Wars take on the egg/sperm interactions quite hilarious.  I love Star Wars, though.  I couldn’t catch any gender connotations, though.  The ships, or sperm, were driven my males, but that just represented that the sperm were from the male reproductive system.  It’s true that the sperm are much faster, and their goal is to reach the egg, just like the fighters were faster than the Death Star, and their goal was to get their little white friends (blasts) inside.  George Lucas cannot be held accountable for the fact that they blew up the Death Star, because it was not his intention to represent gametes.  Unless the guy who merged the two videos thought that sperm blow up the egg, which would mean the guy has NOT been paying attention to science, which would thus exonerate science as the reason for any interpretation of female inferiority, he probably just thought it was funny that sperm dart around the egg like fighter jets around the Death Star, and that the phrase, “that’s one in a million!” relates to the fact that only one in a few million sperm are successful.  Actually, that makes me think it’s making fun of the males now.

I honestly cannot see any female inferiority or male superiority in either the clip or my pretty science books.  And maybe people just interpret things differently; take the constitution for example—old dudes have been arguing over that thing since it’s conception.  So maybe Martin is one party and I’m another, and for the life of us, we can’t understand each other’s views.  To each her own.

PS (and this really has little to do with the assignment): "Supersperm" is a term I created to describe myself as a sperm.  My mother had gotten her fallopian tubes tied nearly three years before I joined the world.  SURPRISE!!!  My brothers used this to make me think Mom didn't want me (kinda like making the little sister believe she was adopted).  Older brothers are way more oppressive than science.

Thursday, February 7, 2008

CRJ-2. The One Time Oil And Water Can Mix

When Carole Vance argues that “gender and sexuality must not be understood as ‘natural’ or unchanging ‘truths’ but as ‘social constructions,’” she means that gender is a production of specific societies in a certain time and place.  The view she is advocating is the social constructionist’s view.  Gender, the sexual identity of a person, is behavior, which is “socially or culturally constructed” and learned from society.  For example, little girls are taught from birth to be feminine—they are wrapped up in pink blankets, given dolls to play with, and encouraged to wear dresses.  Little boys are wrapped in blue, given toy trucks, and wear more masculine clothing.  Being taught what is acceptable, our sexual identities are constructed from learning what society expects.  Vance argues that gender and sexuality is not biological or predetermined, nor is it unchangeable. 

I agree that gender and sexuality are changeable—I was socially brought up as a little feminine girl, but I wanted to play with my brother’s toys and play sports, too.  And I think Jessica Alba is hot, but I’m straight.  I’d change teams for her, though.  There’s proof of malleability.  However, I don’t understand why everyone assumes that there are two possibilities, that is, biology or sociology, and those possibilities are oil and water and can never mix.  It’s one or the other.  I disagree.  I think that every trait is a mixture of nature and nurture, gender and sexuality included.  Genetics and hormones and the differences between males and females cannot be denied—it also explains why people are different, because people are genetically and biologically different.  There are hormonal differences in homosexual people from heterosexuals.  That’s not to say they are deficient in any way, but it is saying that there is an underlying biological difference to explain why varying genders and sexualities are legitimate.  But behaviors are also adjusted by society and what it teaches us to do, how to act.  We learn how to act by observing society.

Essentialism argues that since biology primarily influences the characteristics of humans, that all cultures are similar.  For example, an essentialist would say that sexuality is “predetermined by genetic, biological, or physiological mechanisms and thus not subject to change.”  Well, that’s not entirely true.  There are biological mechanisms which lead to certain tendencies in sexuality, but society plays a role in learning, which may or may not change the outcome of those tendencies.  Biology and society share the role of determining gender and sexuality.

Biological determinism is the belief that one’s biology predetermines his or her behavior.  I think that biology determines what you physically are, and how that plays into society’s roles then shape behavior.  That’s the amazing thing about the brain—we can learn and adapt.  For example, a female with more testosterone than the average girl will appear “butch” or “masculine.”  Society will label her as such.  She may (or may not) react to society’s role for her by embracing the masculine role and feel attraction towards girls.

What really gets me is not Vance’s article, but the initial readings about social and historical constructions of gender (section 1).  I don’t understand why the author feels it necessary to change or attack science.  As a woman in science, nothing I have experienced in my scientific education has led me to think there is a bias.  Now, granted, decades or even centuries ago, there was, because people were too ignorant to study the female body in depth.  But I’m talking now, today, my generation.  Scientific studies seek biological answers to traits.  Scientists aren’t looking to “cure” homosexuals, or even oppress women.  They are trying to explain why differences occur.  I would think that social constructionists would appreciate the proof that different groups aren’t trivial or fictional.  There are biological explanations proving that differences do occur.  Now it’s society’s job to accept that.  To accept that it is natural for differences to occur, that people are inherently different, that the mythical norm doesn’t exist, and we shouldn’t keep striving for it.

Friday, February 1, 2008

CRJ-1. Privilege and Power

            For people to admit they are over-privileged may mean admitting they should relinquish some of their powers and privileges.  On the other hand, referring to others as disadvantaged places the fault not in the hands of those who are privileged, but of those who have failed to gain such privileges.  It does not suggest that the privileged should give up any power; it suggests that the disadvantaged should work harder to be on par with the privileged.

            Or maybe the advantaged just can’t see their own privileges because they were taught that their privileges were simply the norm.  Through school, the media, or any other part of society, privileges are given invisibly (hence, “invisible package”) because they are standardized.  Anything less than privileged is abnormal, and thus can be judged as not good enough or not working hard enough.  You know how society likes to pick on “abnormalities.”

            I could walk into 7-11 at 2am and the cashier would not flinch.  I’m a thin, blonde, white girl—completely harmless.  Lucky for the cashier, I’m more of a pacifist anyway, but how could he know that?  How could he know that I wasn’t packing a hidden weapon waiting for an opportunity to score some extra cash?  Just because of my appearance?  My skin color?  My gender?  If, then, a male of middle-eastern heritage, or a big linebacker-esque black guy walked in right after me, would the cashier feel a sudden chill of fear?  In almost every TV show I’ve seen in which a late-night cashier get robbed at gun-point, it’s been a minority holding the trigger.

            I constantly see the fact that I was born into privilege, but I don’t necessarily link it to my race or gender (other than the fact I could grab a beer at midnight with no weird looks from the cashier).  What I recognize is my socioeconomic class.  I have been taught that the norm is to obtain a college education, and those who do not didn’t have their priorities straight, didn’t work hard enough, or just weren’t smart enough to do it.  They are “disadvantaged.”  But I see as a young adult that the reason I’m getting my degree in May is because my parents have been able to afford to send me here at Virginia Tech for four years, and for another four years in Vet School.  People of the same intelligence as me may be labeled as less because they couldn’t afford to go to college.

            The bootstrap myth alleges that anyone can find economic success; all they need is hard work and ambition.  Well, I won’t negate the importance of hard work, but one usually needs to that initial platform of privilege to assert such hard work; otherwise, they could be working hard scrubbing toilets (I am NOT putting that job down, by the way. Anyone who has lived in a dorm should have a very good appreciation of what they do for us!) earning minimum wage.  Economically speaking, they weren’t successful, and according to the bootstrap myth, it’s either because they didn’t work hard enough or just generally weren’t good enough.  Whatever helps the Wall Street guys sleep better at night.  Maybe they could not afford a college education, and had to make a living somehow.  Where would I be if my parents couldn’t have paid for my education?  I’ve worked my butt off these past four years but if I never had the opportunity to be in college, that hard work wouldn’t have gotten me nearly as far as it has.  I had an opportunity to apply my ambition because I was privileged enough to have one.

            As a female, I have only felt less privileged in two things: they won’t let me play tackle football (even though my older brother taught me how to tackle), and some guys have pursued me only as a sex-object and not a person… and then I’m the “prude” for not putting out.  But then if I had, then I’d be the “slut.”  Great win/win situation there, huh?  Now if a guy is put in the same situation, he’s either a “pimp” for getting the girl in bed or he’s a great catch if he decides to get to know her first.  Whatever, I’ll take the “prude” card over to my “great catch” and get over it.  I still want to play football, and not that fairy-princess flag version, either.

            Switching gears to the part I’ve been avoiding because I’m too sick to be angry.  Homophobia and sexism join forces to become one of the more annoyingly ignorant and intolerant ideals currently infiltrating society’s institutions.  It bases itself on patriarchal power and the “nuclear family” (Dad, Mom, two-and-a-half children and a Labrador Retriever... okay, I added the dog to that, but seriously, it’s not family without the canine addition).  This nuclear family, usually with Dad as the head-of-house, makes the heterosexual man absolutely necessary to society.  This being said, he needs his heterosexual wife to bear his children.  This is the norm that has been ingrained in our minds.  Anything that challenges this norm challenges society itself, and then all Hell breaks loose.  Homosexual men threaten that patriarch figure of the nuclear family.  Men don’t like to give up that power, so homosexual men become victims of ignorant, power-hungry idealists.  Homosexual women, of course, also threaten that nuclear family and patriarchal power because if women have families with women, where do the men go?  Men no longer needed?  Men no longer in power?  Panic!  So lesbians, too, are victimized.

            According to Suzanne Pharr, being labeled a lesbian threatens all women, regardless of sexual orientation.  Homosexual women are no different from heterosexual women on the outside.  Women of both orientations vary in appearance, dating habits (long-term, short-term, etc), and there’s no real way of definitively proving her sexuality.  So anyone can point the finger at any woman to make her an outcast.  If a student dislikes a teacher, he can point his ignorant little finger and have her fired.  This fear of being victimized and ostracized for threatening the norm that society teaches us leads to compulsive heterosexuality, that is, people would rather try being heterosexual, even if they are not, to avoid the backlash.  They step back into the line society drew for them. To make matters worse, those who don’t understand feminism—those who think feminists are just a bunch of man-hating lesbians—associate feminism with lesbianism, so the feminists get the same nasty treatment from them.  Awesome step backwards, society.

I’m starting to see the inequality between the sexes now… a little.