Friday, April 18, 2008

Extra Credit: Born Into Brothels

“Born into Brothels” is a documentary in which Zana helps kids in brothels by teaching them photography. The children like to take pictures wherever they go. Unfortunately, these kids live in filthy living situations and they are forced to do errands for the prostitutes until 11pm at night. They long for a life outside the brothels. One girl wonders what she could become if she could get an education, but “has to accept life as being sad and painful.” The police used to take one of the prostitutes, and her child’s father would go get her. The police only ask if she’s going do it again, and obviously she lies, so they let her go. The police won’t help put an end to the prostitution. One girl says that her father tried to sell her, and that she’s worried that she’ll end up like her mother—a prostitute. She doesn’t want to become that, but it’s hard for her to say no to anyone. Zana is worried about that as well. Another girl is from a family of prostitutes, and her father beat her mother. Suchitra, another girl, is ashamed of it, but her aunt wants to send her to work “in the line” (become a prostitute). She is eventually forced to do so. The conflict for these children is that Zana wants to find good school for them, but who would take children of prostitutes? Also, a boy named Avijit is really good at art and drawing and photography. Wants to put across the behavior of man. His family sells liquor, men get drunk there and pay the women to… be prostitutes. His father smokes hash now and lost his previously good reputation, so his mother left him. The mother lives in the villiage and no one cares about her; mother wants to send boy to London to get education. Zana wants to help him get an education, too. But the conflict remains. She takes the kids to the beach to take pictures and finally have fun as children, because they so rarely get to do so. Back at home the children witness harsh yelling and cussing. Zana tries to put together all the information needed to get the children into schools, but a whole bunch of disorganization to get ration card holds her back. Also, she needs to take all the kids to a doctor to get tested for HIV, and can’t move ahead until she does. Schools won’t take them if they are HIV-positive. Good news, though—they are all negative. Zana raises money by exhibiting and auctioning the children’s pictures. Avijit is invited to go to Amsterdam for World Press Photo, but Zana finds it difficult to get him a passport. Avijit starts to lose hope, and become apathetic. Some of the kids are accepted in a school, which wants girls to go to the university after school. If the girls are admitted in the school, they can be doctors, lawyers, anything. The important thing school wants to ask of the parents: commitment that the kids will not be removed from their studies. The first priority is school.
Zana also continues to find a school for Avijit, saying he is talented and needs help before he goes down wrong path. However, Avijit says he doesn’t want to go to the school if they put him back two grades. Another boy wants to go, anyway. One of the girl’s family won’t let her go to school because it’s a Thursday and her mother died on a Thursday. But it’s the last day to be able to go. She gets to go thanks to Zana. Avajit finally gets his passport and is excited to go to Amsterdam. He feels like taking pictures again, and loses his apathy. He then choses to go to school. Unfortunately, his hash-smoking father won’t let his son go to school. One girl was removed from school by her mother, another girl removed herself, another girl ran away form home to go to school, and other girl’s aunt wouldn’t let her leave the brothel. One boy is still in school. Kochi, a girl, is still in school and happy. A few successes in a world of hopelessness.

One connection to this class is obvious: the way the women are treated as sexual objects, and the way the young girls are forced into the “profession” and not expected to make it as anything more than whores. The women are beated and even killed by their pimps and husbands. They have no rights. The kids and mothers were invited to the exhibition of their photos, but one boy says his mom can’t come because she has to cook. Even the children who dream of leaving this ugly lifestyle still have expectations of their mothers fitting only one role. It’s really sad.

One little girl says “they say it won’t be long” until she “joins the line,” meaning she’ll work as a prostitute. This shocks me because she’s like ten years old! My God, these poor children are being robbed of their childhood and innocence. They are treated horribly, and their parents cuss at them and force them to be practically be slaves. One small boy is even chained. It’s horrible. Another thing that pissed me off is that the zoo animals are underfed and abused (fed plastic bags). Fucking assholes. There’s no respect for live at all here—no respect for the children or animals. I really want to know why don’t they put pants on some of the smaller kids… It’s really sad. One girl thinks she’ll have to end up taking care of her little sister, which would prevent her from going to school and escaping the brothel. Gosh, this is sad. One kid’s mother died when her pimp set her kitchen on fire. What a dickhead. There’s no police involvement, no justice. One poor boy said he “used to want to be a doctor, then an artist… there is nothing called ‘hope’ in my future.” This is so sad. These children want so badly to be something else, but feel trapped in the brothels. Zana helps some of them get into schools, but only a few of them remain there. The brothel sucks them back in. At least a few of them were able to remain in school and be happy for once in their lives, but gosh, what about the rest? It’s so sad that they are forced to continue the vicious cycle of the brothel life…

1 comment:

Donna said...

i agree with you it is all very sad... question - is it hopeless? do the brothels in the film connect at all to our lives?